Influencer-centered crisis communication: a NodeXL social network analysis of a fiscal controversy between Indonesia's finance minister and regional governors on X (Twitter)

Abstract The digital public sphere has become a primary arena for crisis communication, where information about government officials spreads rapidly through social media platforms such as X (formerly Twitter). This study examines a public controversy between Indonesia's Minister of Finance and regional governors over cuts to regional transfer funds in October 2025 and addresses three questions: (1) What structural pattern characterizes the crisis opinion network, and which actors occupy central positions? (2) How are opinion groups distributed, and which narratives and engagement strategies characterize supportive, critical, and moderate clusters? (3) What role do mass media accounts play relative to government actors? Combining social network analysis (SNA) with qualitative content analysis, the study collected network data from X using NodeXL Pro (keywords "Purbaya" AND "Gubernur"; 1,373 accounts and 1,767 edges over 13 days) and manually coded the stance and narrative strategy of 1,531 posts in the 14 main clusters. The network is highly centralized, but its hub is not a government account: a private, non-verified influencer account, through a single widely retweeted post, attracted 37.9% of all incoming ties, and four private influencer accounts together attracted 61.0%. Each major cluster is a star organized around one source post, and 79.6% of all ties are retweets. Coded stance is strongly one-sided: 74.3% of posts support the minister, 25.1% are neutral or informational, and only 0.6% are critical, so no critical cluster emerged. Supportive clusters defend the minister mainly by ridiculing or discrediting the governors and the national parliament, while neutral clusters form around news outlets, which act as secondary hubs (10.5% of incoming ties). The accounts of the ministry and of the governors are nearly absent, each receiving a single tie. These descriptive findings suggest that, in this case, crisis communication on behalf of an official was carried out largely by third-party influencers rather than by the official or the institutions involved. The study offers an exploratory extension of crisis communication theory and tentative implications for network-aware government communication, within the limits of a single-case, single-platform design.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Research Square
Published
2026-11-16
DOI
https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-11419616/v1
Primary Topic
Public Relations and Crisis Communication
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

Influencer-centered crisis communication: a NodeXL social network analysis of a fiscal controversy between Indonesia's finance minister and regional governors on X (Twitter)

Puji Santoso, Muhammad Younus, Faustyna .
2 links
Research Square
Public Relations and Crisis Communication
preprint

Influencer-centered crisis communication: a NodeXL social network analysis of a fiscal controversy between Indonesia's finance minister and regional governors on X (Twitter)

Puji Santoso, Muhammad Younus, Faustyna .
preprint en

Abstract

Abstract The digital public sphere has become a primary arena for crisis communication, where information about government officials spreads rapidly through social media platforms such as X (formerly Twitter). This study examines a public controversy between Indonesia's Minister of Finance and regional governors over cuts to regional transfer funds in October 2025 and addresses three questions: (1) What structural pattern characterizes the crisis opinion network, and which actors occupy central positions? (2) How are opinion groups distributed, and which narratives and engagement strategies characterize supportive, critical, and moderate clusters? (3) What role do mass media accounts play relative to government actors? Combining social network analysis (SNA) with qualitative content analysis, the study collected network data from X using NodeXL Pro (keywords "Purbaya" AND "Gubernur"; 1,373 accounts and 1,767 edges over 13 days) and manually coded the stance and narrative strategy of 1,531 posts in the 14 main clusters. The network is highly centralized, but its hub is not a government account: a private, non-verified influencer account, through a single widely retweeted post, attracted 37.9% of all incoming ties, and four private influencer accounts together attracted 61.0%. Each major cluster is a star organized around one source post, and 79.6% of all ties are retweets. Coded stance is strongly one-sided: 74.3% of posts support the minister, 25.1% are neutral or informational, and only 0.6% are critical, so no critical cluster emerged. Supportive clusters defend the minister mainly by ridiculing or discrediting the governors and the national parliament, while neutral clusters form around news outlets, which act as secondary hubs (10.5% of incoming ties). The accounts of the ministry and of the governors are nearly absent, each receiving a single tie. These descriptive findings suggest that, in this case, crisis communication on behalf of an official was carried out largely by third-party influencers rather than by the official or the institutions involved. The study offers an exploratory extension of crisis communication theory and tentative implications for network-aware government communication, within the limits of a single-case, single-platform design.

Research Square
Muhammadiyah University of Yogyakarta (ID), Universitas Muhammadiyah Sumatera Utara (ID)
Peace, justice, and strong institutions
Public Relations and Crisis Communication
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon