Galactic-Latitude Dependence of the Blend-Covariate Coefficient in Proper-Motion Contamination Tests: A Fifteen-Field Analysis of unTimely Epoch Astrometry

Meisner et al. (2021), reading a figure in Marocco et al. (2021), infer that Cat WISE2020 proper-motion uncertainties near the south ecliptic pole at W1≈ 17.2 are underestimated by ≈ 2.1x. We could not re-derive this; it motivates our analysis but is not an input to it. Using unTimely epoch-level astrometry (from time-resolved unWISE coadds like Cat WISE2020's, but measured with different software), we test whether excess epoch-level scatter tracks an independent blending indicator, fracflux. A protocol written before the main analysis was applied to fifteen fields spanning BGAL = 2.2-77.5° (222,828 sources; 5.68 * 10 ^ 6 epoch records); the last field was added afterwards as an out-of-sample test. The protocol's confirmation criterion fails: the fracflux coefficient has no consistent sign across fields (Cochran's Q = 1276.5 on 14 d.f.; I ^ 2 = 98.9% ) A post-hoc meta-regression shows it rising toward the Galactic plane (31 = 1.158 -0.0370 BGAL]; slope p = 8 * 10 ^ - 4 after scaling for residual heterogeneity), and the slope is negative in all eight model specifications tried. Whether the coefficient changes sign, and at what latitude, depends on the specification (zero crossing 0.2-31.3°); Fields 3 and 8 (BGAL = 2.7°, 8.7°) are significantly reversed in all eight. Leave-one-out prediction gets the sign right in 14 of 15 fields for the executed model, and Field 15's sign was predicted from the other fields before it was processed (on our own record). Two candidate physical accounts we tested are insufficient on their own. A latitude-calibrated score is validated only on these fields. Independent replication, and tests on CatWISE2020's own epoch measurements, remain open.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Figshare
Published
2026-11-16
DOI
https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.35021029
Primary Topic
Stellar, planetary, and galactic studies
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

Galactic-Latitude Dependence of the Blend-Covariate Coefficient in Proper-Motion Contamination Tests: A Fifteen-Field Analysis of unTimely Epoch Astrometry

Ritwik Kumar
Figshare
Stellar, planetary, and galactic studies
preprint

Galactic-Latitude Dependence of the Blend-Covariate Coefficient in Proper-Motion Contamination Tests: A Fifteen-Field Analysis of unTimely Epoch Astrometry

Ritwik Kumar
preprint en

Abstract

Meisner et al. (2021), reading a figure in Marocco et al. (2021), infer that Cat WISE2020 proper-motion uncertainties near the south ecliptic pole at W1≈ 17.2 are underestimated by ≈ 2.1x. We could not re-derive this; it motivates our analysis but is not an input to it. Using unTimely epoch-level astrometry (from time-resolved unWISE coadds like Cat WISE2020's, but measured with different software), we test whether excess epoch-level scatter tracks an independent blending indicator, fracflux. A protocol written before the main analysis was applied to fifteen fields spanning BGAL = 2.2-77.5° (222,828 sources; 5.68 * 10 ^ 6 epoch records); the last field was added afterwards as an out-of-sample test. The protocol's confirmation criterion fails: the fracflux coefficient has no consistent sign across fields (Cochran's Q = 1276.5 on 14 d.f.; I ^ 2 = 98.9% ) A post-hoc meta-regression shows it rising toward the Galactic plane (31 = 1.158 -0.0370 BGAL]; slope p = 8 * 10 ^ - 4 after scaling for residual heterogeneity), and the slope is negative in all eight model specifications tried. Whether the coefficient changes sign, and at what latitude, depends on the specification (zero crossing 0.2-31.3°); Fields 3 and 8 (BGAL = 2.7°, 8.7°) are significantly reversed in all eight. Leave-one-out prediction gets the sign right in 14 of 15 fields for the executed model, and Field 15's sign was predicted from the other fields before it was processed (on our own record). Two candidate physical accounts we tested are insufficient on their own. A latitude-calibrated score is validated only on these fields. Independent replication, and tests on CatWISE2020's own epoch measurements, remain open.

Figshare
Stellar, planetary, and galactic studies
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon