Evaluating augmented reality visualization methods for underground utilities using affordance theory and task load analysis

Purpose Effective visualization of underground utilities is critical for preventing accidental damage during excavation. Surface markings and two-dimensional drawings are widely used to avoid utility damage, but they offer limited spatial context. augmented reality (AR) offers a complementary way to enhance on-site visualization of verified utility information, but there is limited empirical evidence comparing alternative AR visualization methods. Focusing on tablet-based video see-through (VST) AR in a controlled experimental context, this study evaluates four AR methods for visualizing underground utilities, including X-Ray, Shadow, Cross-sectional, and a newly developed combination method, to identify which approaches best support underground utilities visualization. Design/methodology/approach This study systematically compares four AR visualization methods through a controlled within-subject experiment with 60 participants. The experiment was conducted in a controlled environment using simulated underground utility visualization tasks. Using the Theory of Affordances and Task Load analysis, the collected data were analyzed to identify key factors influencing effective AR implementation in underground utility visualization. Findings The findings suggest that X-Ray and combination may be useful visualization options when clear interpretation of underground utility position and depth is required. The two methods showed comparable results across the measured affordance and task-load outcomes, while both generally performed better than Shadow. Age was associated with task load and with sensory and cognitive affordance scores, whereas AR familiarity was not a significant predictor in the mixed-effects models. However, because the study was conducted in a controlled environment with a sample consisting primarily of postgraduate students rather than in live real-world excavation settings with professional excavators, the findings should be interpreted as context-specific evidence. Practical implications This study contributes to existing literature by advancing our understanding of the suitability and effectiveness of different AR visualization methods for underground utilities from a user-centered perspective. Future AR systems should prioritize Combination or X-Ray methods when spatial understanding is critical. The newly developed Combination visualization demonstrated superior performance and lower task load demand. The results of this study indicate that AR familiarity reduces perceived task load, suggesting value in training. Also, age is a significant factor in task load and perceived affordances. However, because the study was conducted in a controlled environment with a sample consisting primarily of postgraduate students rather than in live real-world excavation settings with professional excavators, the findings should be interpreted as context-specific evidence. Originality/value This study provides a user-centered and systematic comparison of underground utility AR visualization methods using Affordance Theory and task load. Its originality lies in extending the evaluation of AR visualization beyond general system usability by linking visual cue design with perceived affordance, task load, error tendency, and user preference. In doing so, the study explains how different visualization methods support interpretation of excavation-relevant visual information and provides evidence-based guidance for AR-enabled underground infrastructure management.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Smart and Sustainable Built Environment
Published
2026-11-16
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1108/sasbe-01-2026-0004
Primary Topic
Augmented Reality Applications
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Evaluating augmented reality visualization methods for underground utilities using affordance theory and task load analysis

Hesam Khorrami Shad, Zhenan Feng, Tak Wing Yiu, Ruggiero Lovreglio et al.
Smart and Sustainable Built Environment
Augmented Reality Applications
article

Evaluating augmented reality visualization methods for underground utilities using affordance theory and task load analysis

Hesam Khorrami Shad, Zhenan Feng, Tak Wing Yiu, Ruggiero Lovreglio, Zhidong Xu, Daniel Paes
article en

Abstract

Purpose Effective visualization of underground utilities is critical for preventing accidental damage during excavation. Surface markings and two-dimensional drawings are widely used to avoid utility damage, but they offer limited spatial context. augmented reality (AR) offers a complementary way to enhance on-site visualization of verified utility information, but there is limited empirical evidence comparing alternative AR visualization methods. Focusing on tablet-based video see-through (VST) AR in a controlled experimental context, this study evaluates four AR methods for visualizing underground utilities, including X-Ray, Shadow, Cross-sectional, and a newly developed combination method, to identify which approaches best support underground utilities visualization. Design/methodology/approach This study systematically compares four AR visualization methods through a controlled within-subject experiment with 60 participants. The experiment was conducted in a controlled environment using simulated underground utility visualization tasks. Using the Theory of Affordances and Task Load analysis, the collected data were analyzed to identify key factors influencing effective AR implementation in underground utility visualization. Findings The findings suggest that X-Ray and combination may be useful visualization options when clear interpretation of underground utility position and depth is required. The two methods showed comparable results across the measured affordance and task-load outcomes, while both generally performed better than Shadow. Age was associated with task load and with sensory and cognitive affordance scores, whereas AR familiarity was not a significant predictor in the mixed-effects models. However, because the study was conducted in a controlled environment with a sample consisting primarily of postgraduate students rather than in live real-world excavation settings with professional excavators, the findings should be interpreted as context-specific evidence. Practical implications This study contributes to existing literature by advancing our understanding of the suitability and effectiveness of different AR visualization methods for underground utilities from a user-centered perspective. Future AR systems should prioritize Combination or X-Ray methods when spatial understanding is critical. The newly developed Combination visualization demonstrated superior performance and lower task load demand. The results of this study indicate that AR familiarity reduces perceived task load, suggesting value in training. Also, age is a significant factor in task load and perceived affordances. However, because the study was conducted in a controlled environment with a sample consisting primarily of postgraduate students rather than in live real-world excavation settings with professional excavators, the findings should be interpreted as context-specific evidence. Originality/value This study provides a user-centered and systematic comparison of underground utility AR visualization methods using Affordance Theory and task load. Its originality lies in extending the evaluation of AR visualization beyond general system usability by linking visual cue design with perceived affordance, task load, error tendency, and user preference. In doing so, the study explains how different visualization methods support interpretation of excavation-relevant visual information and provides evidence-based guidance for AR-enabled underground infrastructure management.

Smart and Sustainable Built Environment
UNSW Sydney (AU), Massey University (NZ)
Augmented Reality Applications
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon