Statutory duty of candour: a comparative analysis of legislative frameworks

OBJECTIVE: Open disclosure following patient safety events is essential for safety, learning, and restoring trust between patients and health services. However, voluntary frameworks have been inconsistently applied. Governments have therefore introduced statutory duty of candour (SDC) frameworks, requiring health services to provide patients and families with an honest account, an apology, and information about steps to prevent recurrence. This study compares the legislative design of organisational SDC frameworks across English-speaking jurisdictions with enacted legislation and examines how design differences may plausibly relate to implementation challenges. METHODS: A comparative policy document analysis with narrative synthesis was undertaken. Primary Acts, subordinate legislation, statutory instruments, and regulator-endorsed guidance were identified through targeted searches of legislation repositories and government and regulator websites and extracted into a comparative matrix. The Health Policy Triangle was used as the analytical framework. RESULTS: Thirty-four documents were included across four jurisdictions: Victoria (Australia), England, Scotland, and Wales. All share a common legislative construction but differ substantially across seven themes: harm thresholds, procedural obligations, legal protections, enforcement consequences, training requirements, transparency mechanisms, and public reporting. Victoria is the only jurisdiction in which internal safety reviews are protected by law from legal proceedings. England is the only jurisdiction where non-compliance constitutes a criminal offence. Scotland and Wales are the only jurisdictions with legislated training and clinician support obligations, and they alone require mandatory annual public reporting of candour activity. CONCLUSION: All four jurisdictions have enacted organisational SDC frameworks and share a common legislative construction but differ substantially in design. These design differences offer plausible explanations for documented implementation challenges.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Australian Health Review
Published
2026-11-16
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1071/ah26087
Primary Topic
Patient Safety and Medication Errors
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Statutory duty of candour: a comparative analysis of legislative frameworks

Peter Alistair Cameron, Paul Jennings, Reema Harrison, Gerard O’Reilly et al.
4 links
Australian Health Review
Patient Safety and Medication Errors
article

Statutory duty of candour: a comparative analysis of legislative frameworks

Peter Alistair Cameron, Paul Jennings, Reema Harrison, Gerard O’Reilly, Corey Adams, Emma Keating
article en

Abstract

OBJECTIVE: Open disclosure following patient safety events is essential for safety, learning, and restoring trust between patients and health services. However, voluntary frameworks have been inconsistently applied. Governments have therefore introduced statutory duty of candour (SDC) frameworks, requiring health services to provide patients and families with an honest account, an apology, and information about steps to prevent recurrence. This study compares the legislative design of organisational SDC frameworks across English-speaking jurisdictions with enacted legislation and examines how design differences may plausibly relate to implementation challenges. METHODS: A comparative policy document analysis with narrative synthesis was undertaken. Primary Acts, subordinate legislation, statutory instruments, and regulator-endorsed guidance were identified through targeted searches of legislation repositories and government and regulator websites and extracted into a comparative matrix. The Health Policy Triangle was used as the analytical framework. RESULTS: Thirty-four documents were included across four jurisdictions: Victoria (Australia), England, Scotland, and Wales. All share a common legislative construction but differ substantially across seven themes: harm thresholds, procedural obligations, legal protections, enforcement consequences, training requirements, transparency mechanisms, and public reporting. Victoria is the only jurisdiction in which internal safety reviews are protected by law from legal proceedings. England is the only jurisdiction where non-compliance constitutes a criminal offence. Scotland and Wales are the only jurisdictions with legislated training and clinician support obligations, and they alone require mandatory annual public reporting of candour activity. CONCLUSION: All four jurisdictions have enacted organisational SDC frameworks and share a common legislative construction but differ substantially in design. These design differences offer plausible explanations for documented implementation challenges.

Australian Health ReviewVol. 50(6)
La Trobe University (AU), General Department of Preventive Medicine (VN), Bendigo Health (AU), Monash University (AU), Macquarie University (AU)
Peace, justice, and strong institutions, Good health and well-being
Patient Safety and Medication Errors
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon