Gambling in Disguise? A Mixed-Method Examination of Prediction Market Users, Event Preferences, Motives, and Problem Gambling

Background and Aims: Prediction markets have exploded in popularity since a 2024 US court case concluded they should be regulated as financial products, even when used to wager on sport event outcomes. This study therefore explored the convergence of prediction markets and traditional forms of gambling, in particular sports betting. Specifically, we explored whether higher rates of prediction market use would associate with demographic (i.e., age, sex, income, education) and psychological (i.e., impulsivity, financially focused self-concept, psychological distress, problematic alcohol/cannabis use) predictors of problem gambling, alongside direct measures of problem gambling (e.g., Problem Gambling Severity Index [PGSI], Gambling Fallacies Measure [GFM], and Positive Play Scale [PPS]). Participants’ motivations for using prediction markets were obtained via free-text responses.Methods: Valid data were obtained from a preregistered online cross-sectional study of 938 prediction market users via Prolific in late 2026. A Cochran’s Q test and a z-test explored whether most participants used prediction markets for sports betting and also engaged with conventional gambling products. Ordinal logistic models explored whether higher rates of self-reported prediction market use correlated with demographic, psychological, and gambling predictors of interest. Qualitative inductive content analysis explored participants’ motivations.Results: As hypothesised, sports contracts were the most popular (81.2%), which was significantly greater than the next most popular category of financial events (55.2%,p<.001). A significant majority of prediction market users also engaged in traditional gambling, (84%;z=20.83,p<.001). As hypothesised, younger age (OR=1.02,p=.048) and being male (OR=1.39, p=.048) were associated with greater prediction market frequency. However, income was not (LRχ²(7)=13.49, p=.061). Being more educated was significantly associated with greater prediction market frequency overall (LRχ²(4)=11.85,p=.025); although no individual category differed from its reference group. As hypothesised, higher scores on four out of five facets of impulsivity (x2(1)=8.25-22.67,ps<.005), higher financially focused self-concept (x2(1)=13.02,p<.001), higher psychological distress (x2(1)=4.11,p<.001), and higher problematic alcohol (x2(1)=15.42,p<.001) and cannabis use (x2(1)=15.71,p<.001) were all associated with greater prediction market use, as was higher PGSI (x2(1)=93.30,p<.001), lower PPS (x2(1)=32.99-65.09,p<.001), but lower GFM was contrastingly not (x2(1)=3.84,p=.050). Participants most commonly reported using prediction markets to win money (52.54%), and reported using them over conventional sportsbooks due to better user-interfaces (36.58%).Conclusion: US-based prediction market users fit many hallmark characteristics of conventional gambling users, questioning prediction markets’ regulation as financial products.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
PsyArXiv (OSF Preprints)
Published
2026-11-16
DOI
https://doi.org/10.31234/osf.io/mb4xr
Primary Topic
Gambling Behavior and Treatments
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

Gambling in Disguise? A Mixed-Method Examination of Prediction Market Users, Event Preferences, Motives, and Problem Gambling

Joshua Briggs Grubbs, N. Güney, Hyoun Soo Andrew Kim, Philip Newall et al.
1 links
PsyArXiv (OSF Preprints)
Gambling Behavior and Treatments
preprint

Gambling in Disguise? A Mixed-Method Examination of Prediction Market Users, Event Preferences, Motives, and Problem Gambling

Joshua Briggs Grubbs, N. Güney, Hyoun Soo Andrew Kim, Philip Newall, Curtis Wagter, Maya Thulin, Danielle Shinbine
preprint en

Abstract

Background and Aims: Prediction markets have exploded in popularity since a 2024 US court case concluded they should be regulated as financial products, even when used to wager on sport event outcomes. This study therefore explored the convergence of prediction markets and traditional forms of gambling, in particular sports betting. Specifically, we explored whether higher rates of prediction market use would associate with demographic (i.e., age, sex, income, education) and psychological (i.e., impulsivity, financially focused self-concept, psychological distress, problematic alcohol/cannabis use) predictors of problem gambling, alongside direct measures of problem gambling (e.g., Problem Gambling Severity Index [PGSI], Gambling Fallacies Measure [GFM], and Positive Play Scale [PPS]). Participants’ motivations for using prediction markets were obtained via free-text responses.Methods: Valid data were obtained from a preregistered online cross-sectional study of 938 prediction market users via Prolific in late 2026. A Cochran’s Q test and a z-test explored whether most participants used prediction markets for sports betting and also engaged with conventional gambling products. Ordinal logistic models explored whether higher rates of self-reported prediction market use correlated with demographic, psychological, and gambling predictors of interest. Qualitative inductive content analysis explored participants’ motivations.Results: As hypothesised, sports contracts were the most popular (81.2%), which was significantly greater than the next most popular category of financial events (55.2%,p<.001). A significant majority of prediction market users also engaged in traditional gambling, (84%;z=20.83,p<.001). As hypothesised, younger age (OR=1.02,p=.048) and being male (OR=1.39, p=.048) were associated with greater prediction market frequency. However, income was not (LRχ²(7)=13.49, p=.061). Being more educated was significantly associated with greater prediction market frequency overall (LRχ²(4)=11.85,p=.025); although no individual category differed from its reference group. As hypothesised, higher scores on four out of five facets of impulsivity (x2(1)=8.25-22.67,ps<.005), higher financially focused self-concept (x2(1)=13.02,p<.001), higher psychological distress (x2(1)=4.11,p<.001), and higher problematic alcohol (x2(1)=15.42,p<.001) and cannabis use (x2(1)=15.71,p<.001) were all associated with greater prediction market use, as was higher PGSI (x2(1)=93.30,p<.001), lower PPS (x2(1)=32.99-65.09,p<.001), but lower GFM was contrastingly not (x2(1)=3.84,p=.050). Participants most commonly reported using prediction markets to win money (52.54%), and reported using them over conventional sportsbooks due to better user-interfaces (36.58%).Conclusion: US-based prediction market users fit many hallmark characteristics of conventional gambling users, questioning prediction markets’ regulation as financial products.

PsyArXiv (OSF Preprints)
University of British Columbia (CA)
Good health and well-being
Gambling Behavior and Treatments
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon