The Urban Sports Space Paradox: Why High-Quality Public Facilities Do Not Necessarily Translate into Equitable Participation Opportunities

Abstract Improving the quality of public sports facilities generally raises aggregate participation opportunities, yet such improvements do not translate linearly into equitable participation benefits, because spatial benefits are partly capitalized through land and housing markets and interact with socio-spatial sorting. Using Shanghai's 16 districts, this paper integrates 19,108 public sports facility points of interest, WorldPop population grids, and second-hand housing prices to construct a participation opportunity index, and uses agent-based simulation to identify the boundary conditions of benefit-equity decoupling. Results show a gradient of participation opportunity, high in the central city and low in the outer suburbs; the population-weighted nearest-facility distance is 688.5 m, from 182.0 m in Huangpu to 817.1 m in Chongming. District-level log-linear regressions show the index is explained mainly by land-market variables: the coefficient on log housing price is 1.43 (t = 7.49), per capita disposable income correlates with the index at 0.88, while facilities per 10,000 residents are insignificant (− 0.31, t = − 0.85) and resident population has a coefficient of − 0.43 (t = − 2.47), with overall R² = 0.879. The housing-burden index rises from 0.24 in Jinshan to 0.96 in Huangpu. When land-market pressure, transport accessibility, and economic burden reach specific combinations, spatial quality and equitable benefit decouple systematically. An agent-based model calibrated with district-level data and 200 Monte Carlo parameter draws shows that a combined policy of transport improvement, targeted supply, and housing-affordability support raises low-income groups' equity benefit by about 9.7%, outperforming any single policy. This framework extends to parks, schools, and healthcare.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Research Square
Published
2026-11-16
DOI
https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-11488329/v1
Primary Topic
Urban Transport and Accessibility
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

The Urban Sports Space Paradox: Why High-Quality Public Facilities Do Not Necessarily Translate into Equitable Participation Opportunities

XUZE LIU, XIAOPEI ZHANG
3 links
Research Square
Urban Transport and Accessibility
preprint

The Urban Sports Space Paradox: Why High-Quality Public Facilities Do Not Necessarily Translate into Equitable Participation Opportunities

XUZE LIU, XIAOPEI ZHANG
preprint en

Abstract

Abstract Improving the quality of public sports facilities generally raises aggregate participation opportunities, yet such improvements do not translate linearly into equitable participation benefits, because spatial benefits are partly capitalized through land and housing markets and interact with socio-spatial sorting. Using Shanghai's 16 districts, this paper integrates 19,108 public sports facility points of interest, WorldPop population grids, and second-hand housing prices to construct a participation opportunity index, and uses agent-based simulation to identify the boundary conditions of benefit-equity decoupling. Results show a gradient of participation opportunity, high in the central city and low in the outer suburbs; the population-weighted nearest-facility distance is 688.5 m, from 182.0 m in Huangpu to 817.1 m in Chongming. District-level log-linear regressions show the index is explained mainly by land-market variables: the coefficient on log housing price is 1.43 (t = 7.49), per capita disposable income correlates with the index at 0.88, while facilities per 10,000 residents are insignificant (− 0.31, t = − 0.85) and resident population has a coefficient of − 0.43 (t = − 2.47), with overall R² = 0.879. The housing-burden index rises from 0.24 in Jinshan to 0.96 in Huangpu. When land-market pressure, transport accessibility, and economic burden reach specific combinations, spatial quality and equitable benefit decouple systematically. An agent-based model calibrated with district-level data and 200 Monte Carlo parameter draws shows that a combined policy of transport improvement, targeted supply, and housing-affordability support raises low-income groups' equity benefit by about 9.7%, outperforming any single policy. This framework extends to parks, schools, and healthcare.

Research Square
Henan University (CN)
Reduced inequalities, Sustainable cities and communities
Urban Transport and Accessibility
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon