Enduring Property Versatility

Abstract This is a contribution to a symposium on David Liebesman and Ofra Magidor’s outstanding book, Property Versatility and Copredication . We focus on the implications of their view for foundational metaphysics—specifically, traditional ontological categories: ‘abstract/concrete’, ‘material/immaterial’, and endurantism vs. the rest. We agree the abstract/concrete and material/immaterial dichotomies should be sidelined or eliminated altogether. But we categorically disagree with the deflationary view they entertain regarding endurantism in particular and location more generally. We argue their view is committed to endurantism. But this is a feature , not a bug. In Property Versatility and Copredication (hereafter, ‘ PVC ’) David Liebesman and Ofra Magidor (hereafter, ‘L&M’) transform our understanding of the metaphysics of properties, types, and kinds. They argue that properties are versatile in a way that has largely gone unnoticed. Property versatility is the commonplace view that properties can be had in many ways; fire engines and frocks might both be red despite differences in hue, brightness, saturation, material, etc. But property versatility in L&M’s hands is a sort of generalization of the commonplace view. And it’s the versatility of property versatility that has largely gone unnoticed. L&M contend that property versatility versatility (hereafter, ‘PVV’) has far-reaching implications for metaphysics. To reiterate: This book is transformational. We recommend it unreservedly. L&M advocate PVV as the solution to ‘the problem of copredication’. PVV also plays an important role in L&M’s solution to ‘the counting problem’ presented at PVC ’s outset: There are three copies of War and Peace on an otherwise empty shelf (Fig. 1).

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Research Square
Published
2026-11-16
DOI
https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-11355227/v1
Primary Topic
Philosophy and Theoretical Science
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

Enduring Property Versatility

Chris Tillman, Joshua Spencer
1 links
Research Square
Philosophy and Theoretical Science
preprint

Enduring Property Versatility

Chris Tillman, Joshua Spencer
preprint en

Abstract

Abstract This is a contribution to a symposium on David Liebesman and Ofra Magidor’s outstanding book, Property Versatility and Copredication . We focus on the implications of their view for foundational metaphysics—specifically, traditional ontological categories: ‘abstract/concrete’, ‘material/immaterial’, and endurantism vs. the rest. We agree the abstract/concrete and material/immaterial dichotomies should be sidelined or eliminated altogether. But we categorically disagree with the deflationary view they entertain regarding endurantism in particular and location more generally. We argue their view is committed to endurantism. But this is a feature , not a bug. In Property Versatility and Copredication (hereafter, ‘ PVC ’) David Liebesman and Ofra Magidor (hereafter, ‘L&M’) transform our understanding of the metaphysics of properties, types, and kinds. They argue that properties are versatile in a way that has largely gone unnoticed. Property versatility is the commonplace view that properties can be had in many ways; fire engines and frocks might both be red despite differences in hue, brightness, saturation, material, etc. But property versatility in L&M’s hands is a sort of generalization of the commonplace view. And it’s the versatility of property versatility that has largely gone unnoticed. L&M contend that property versatility versatility (hereafter, ‘PVV’) has far-reaching implications for metaphysics. To reiterate: This book is transformational. We recommend it unreservedly. L&M advocate PVV as the solution to ‘the problem of copredication’. PVV also plays an important role in L&M’s solution to ‘the counting problem’ presented at PVC ’s outset: There are three copies of War and Peace on an otherwise empty shelf (Fig. 1).

Research Square
University of Wisconsin–Milwaukee (US), University of Manitoba (CA)
Philosophy and Theoretical Science
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon