Pandemic-era clustering of fitness deficits: an eight-year within-student study
Abstract Background Physical-fitness surveillance almost always reports one indicator at a time, so it cannot show whether different deficits occur together in the same person, or whether a major health shock changes that tendency. Chronic-disease epidemiology has shown that when conditions cluster within an individual, the clustering itself carries information beyond any single condition. We asked whether the COVID-19 pandemic increased the within-individual co-occurrence of fitness deficits in young adults, beyond any uniform decline in single indicators, and whether the change was concentrated in the cardiorespiratory system. Methods We used eight academic years of mandatory fitness testing (2018–2025) from one Chinese university, comprising 276,406 records from 101,867 repeatedly tested students. We first confirmed, as background, that single indicators declined, comparing each student with their own baseline. We then tested whether four binary deficits (endurance, standing long jump, strength, vital capacity) co-occurred more than expected during the pandemic, using co-occurrence ratios, latent-variable models, a within-student comparison of the number of deficits, and a network permutation test. All estimates are associations, not causal effects. Results Deficits became markedly more likely to co-occur within the same student during the pandemic. Because the co-occurrence ratio already accounts for how often each deficit occurs alone, its rise (men 1.27 to 1.40, women 1.53 to 2.09) indicates tighter clustering rather than more frequent failure. A cardiorespiratory deficit class in men rose from 6.2% (2021) to 9.3% (2023), and a threshold-free profile analysis reproduced the expansion, ruling out a scoring artifact. Against each student's own trajectory, the number of deficits rose 0.99 more during the pandemic than in a placebo window in men (95% CI 0.96 to 1.02) and 0.74 in women. The deficit network became denser (global strength 0.58 to 0.96, permutation P = 0.001). The change was cardiorespiratory-selective, with vital capacity and endurance worsening while jump and sprint did not. Conclusions During the pandemic, fitness deficits became more likely to accumulate within the same young adult, a structural change concentrated in the cardiorespiratory system. Surveillance that follows individuals over time and monitors the number and combination of deficits against absolute health standards would detect this, whereas single-indicator monitoring against relative ranks would not.
Authors
- Xiaodi Wu
- Huiyang Xiao
Institutions
- Guangdong University of Technology (CN)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Research Square
- Published
- 2026-11-16
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-11120694/v1
- Primary Topic
- Physical Activity and Health
- Type
- preprint