Open reduction of the femoral butterfly fragment in closed femoral shaft fractures is associated with a higher rate of reoperation to promote union: a retrospective clinical cohort

OBJECTIVES: To evaluate whether the presence of and/or open reduction of a butterfly fragment in closed femoral shaft fractures was associated with reoperation to promote union. METHODS: Design: Retrospective cohort. SETTING: Single Level I Trauma Center. PATIENT SELECTION CRITERIA: Included were patients who underwent surgical fixation of an acute OTA/AO 32A-C femoral shaft fracture between January 2017 and January 2024. Patients younger than 18 years, nonunion surgeries, <3 months follow-up, periprosthetic fractures, and open fractures were excluded. OUTCOME MEASURES AND COMPARISONS: Patient demographics were retrospectively collected. A butterfly fragment was defined as a singular, wedge-shaped segment of comminution from the diaphysis of the femur. Groups were stratified based on the presence or absence of a butterfly fragment. The primary outcome was reoperation to promote union. Secondary outcomes included fracture-related infection (FRI) and presence of post-operative cortical step sign (CSS). Comparisons of primary and secondary outcomes were made between patients with and without a femoral butterfly fragment. A subgroup analysis was performed within the butterfly fragment group comparing open versus closed reduction of the butterfly fragment. RESULTS: 139 patients were included: 99 (71.2%) without a butterfly fragment (mean age 38.5years, range 18-92years; 62.6% male) and 40 (28.8%) with a butterfly fragment (mean age 35.5years, range 18-96years; 75.0% male). 10 (10.1%) patients without a butterfly fragment and 8 (20.0%) patients with a butterfly fragment underwent reoperation to promote union (p=0.2). Of the 40 patients with a butterfly fragment, 9 (22.5%) had open reduction of the butterfly fragment with cable fixation and 31 (77.5%) did not. The mean proximal and distal displacement of the butterfly fragment did not differ significantly between those managed with open versus closed reduction (38.8mm vs 35.4mm and 20.3mm vs 18.9mm, respectively, p>0.05). Open reduction to the butterfly fragment compared to closed reduction was associated with a higher rate of reoperation to promote union (66.7% vs 6.5%, p<0.01). CONCLUSIONS: Open reduction of the butterfly fragment in closed femoral shaft fractures was associated with a higher rate of reoperation to promote union compared to closed reduction. These findings emphasize biologic preservation. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: III.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Journal of Orthopaedic Trauma
Published
2026-11-16
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1097/bot.0000000000003316
Primary Topic
Bone fractures and treatments
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Open reduction of the femoral butterfly fragment in closed femoral shaft fractures is associated with a higher rate of reoperation to promote union: a retrospective clinical cohort

Justin E. Hellwinkel, Nathaniel Elliot Schaffer, Adam Michael Schlauch, Timothy Domashevich et al.
Journal of Orthopaedic Trauma
Bone fractures and treatments
article

Open reduction of the femoral butterfly fragment in closed femoral shaft fractures is associated with a higher rate of reoperation to promote union: a retrospective clinical cohort

Justin E. Hellwinkel, Nathaniel Elliot Schaffer, Adam Michael Schlauch, Timothy Domashevich, Anna Zakusylo, Garrett Ball, Cyril Mauffrey, Oluwatobi Onafowokan, Victoria Kennerly, Brett Biedermann
article en

Abstract

OBJECTIVES: To evaluate whether the presence of and/or open reduction of a butterfly fragment in closed femoral shaft fractures was associated with reoperation to promote union. METHODS: Design: Retrospective cohort. SETTING: Single Level I Trauma Center. PATIENT SELECTION CRITERIA: Included were patients who underwent surgical fixation of an acute OTA/AO 32A-C femoral shaft fracture between January 2017 and January 2024. Patients younger than 18 years, nonunion surgeries, <3 months follow-up, periprosthetic fractures, and open fractures were excluded. OUTCOME MEASURES AND COMPARISONS: Patient demographics were retrospectively collected. A butterfly fragment was defined as a singular, wedge-shaped segment of comminution from the diaphysis of the femur. Groups were stratified based on the presence or absence of a butterfly fragment. The primary outcome was reoperation to promote union. Secondary outcomes included fracture-related infection (FRI) and presence of post-operative cortical step sign (CSS). Comparisons of primary and secondary outcomes were made between patients with and without a femoral butterfly fragment. A subgroup analysis was performed within the butterfly fragment group comparing open versus closed reduction of the butterfly fragment. RESULTS: 139 patients were included: 99 (71.2%) without a butterfly fragment (mean age 38.5years, range 18-92years; 62.6% male) and 40 (28.8%) with a butterfly fragment (mean age 35.5years, range 18-96years; 75.0% male). 10 (10.1%) patients without a butterfly fragment and 8 (20.0%) patients with a butterfly fragment underwent reoperation to promote union (p=0.2). Of the 40 patients with a butterfly fragment, 9 (22.5%) had open reduction of the butterfly fragment with cable fixation and 31 (77.5%) did not. The mean proximal and distal displacement of the butterfly fragment did not differ significantly between those managed with open versus closed reduction (38.8mm vs 35.4mm and 20.3mm vs 18.9mm, respectively, p>0.05). Open reduction to the butterfly fragment compared to closed reduction was associated with a higher rate of reoperation to promote union (66.7% vs 6.5%, p<0.01). CONCLUSIONS: Open reduction of the butterfly fragment in closed femoral shaft fractures was associated with a higher rate of reoperation to promote union compared to closed reduction. These findings emphasize biologic preservation. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: III.

Journal of Orthopaedic Trauma
Denver Health Medical Center (US), University of Colorado Anschutz Medical Campus (US), University of Colorado Denver (US)
Good health and well-being
Bone fractures and treatments
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon