Numerical modelling of mixed convection over slender cylinders: a critical review of transport mechanisms, computational methods and advanced nanofluids

Purpose This critical study aims to offer a mechanistic assessment of numerical studies on mixed-convection heat and mass transfer over slender cylinders and related thin geometries. It aims to establish a coherent framework for classifying the literature by dominant transport mechanisms, modelling assumptions and computational practices, and to explain the origins of apparently conflicting trends in surface drag, heat and mass transfer and entropy generation. Design/methodology/approach The review uses a mechanism-based synthesis to classify and critically interrogate studies of single, double and multiple diffusion; buoyancy-assisting and buoyancy-opposing flows; suction and injection; rotation; nonlinear stretching; porous resistance; radiation; viscous dissipation; chemical reaction; surface roughness; non-Newtonian rheology; and mono-, hybrid-, ternary- and tetra-hybrid nanofluids. Within each category, it systematically examines the governing assumptions, boundary and far-field conditions, constitutive and effective-property models, nondimensionalisation, parameter regimes and numerical treatments. Particular attention is given to the suitability, verification, convergence and validation of finite-difference, Keller-box, quasilinearisation, shooting, boundary-value, collocation, homotopy and spectral methods. Findings Transverse curvature enters the leading-order transport balance when the boundary-layer thickness is comparable to the cylinder radius; neglecting it can therefore compromise predictions of wall shear, heat transfer and mass transfer. Apparent contradictions in the literature arise predominantly from differences in buoyancy orientation, curvature magnitude, wall thermal and species conditions, constitutive and effective-property correlations, parameter ranges, nondimensionalisation and numerical treatment, rather than from genuine physical inconsistency. Iterative convergence alone does not establish numerical credibility. Reliable solutions also require grid- or collocation-point independence, residual assessment, far-field truncation tests, benchmark comparisons, branch-continuation and stability analyses where multiple solutions occur and, whenever feasible, validation against experiments or independent high-fidelity simulations. Advanced nanofluids may improve heat transfer, but the reported gains are strongly model-dependent and may be offset by increased viscosity, wall shear, pressure-drop demands, entropy generation, suspension-instability constraints and uncertainty in thermophysical property correlations. Originality/value Unlike conventional chronological surveys, this review offers a unified, mechanism-based and numerically rigorous synthesis of mixed convection over slender cylinders. It introduces a regime-aware framework that reconciles apparently conflicting transport trends by linking them to governing physical mechanisms, modelling assumptions, boundary conditions and computational practices. The framework also evaluates thermal enhancement against hydrodynamic penalties, and against physical realism, reproducibility and validation, thereby providing a robust basis for comparing existing studies and for developing performance-balanced models for slender-cylinder transport systems.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
International Journal of Numerical Methods for Heat &amp Fluid Flow
Published
2026-11-16
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1108/hff-08-2026-1243
Primary Topic
Nanofluid Flow and Heat Transfer
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Numerical modelling of mixed convection over slender cylinders: a critical review of transport mechanisms, computational methods and advanced nanofluids

E. Momoniat, Prabhugouda Mallanagouda Patil
International Journal of Numerical Methods for Heat &amp Fluid Flow
Nanofluid Flow and Heat Transfer
article

Numerical modelling of mixed convection over slender cylinders: a critical review of transport mechanisms, computational methods and advanced nanofluids

E. Momoniat, Prabhugouda Mallanagouda Patil
article en

Abstract

Purpose This critical study aims to offer a mechanistic assessment of numerical studies on mixed-convection heat and mass transfer over slender cylinders and related thin geometries. It aims to establish a coherent framework for classifying the literature by dominant transport mechanisms, modelling assumptions and computational practices, and to explain the origins of apparently conflicting trends in surface drag, heat and mass transfer and entropy generation. Design/methodology/approach The review uses a mechanism-based synthesis to classify and critically interrogate studies of single, double and multiple diffusion; buoyancy-assisting and buoyancy-opposing flows; suction and injection; rotation; nonlinear stretching; porous resistance; radiation; viscous dissipation; chemical reaction; surface roughness; non-Newtonian rheology; and mono-, hybrid-, ternary- and tetra-hybrid nanofluids. Within each category, it systematically examines the governing assumptions, boundary and far-field conditions, constitutive and effective-property models, nondimensionalisation, parameter regimes and numerical treatments. Particular attention is given to the suitability, verification, convergence and validation of finite-difference, Keller-box, quasilinearisation, shooting, boundary-value, collocation, homotopy and spectral methods. Findings Transverse curvature enters the leading-order transport balance when the boundary-layer thickness is comparable to the cylinder radius; neglecting it can therefore compromise predictions of wall shear, heat transfer and mass transfer. Apparent contradictions in the literature arise predominantly from differences in buoyancy orientation, curvature magnitude, wall thermal and species conditions, constitutive and effective-property correlations, parameter ranges, nondimensionalisation and numerical treatment, rather than from genuine physical inconsistency. Iterative convergence alone does not establish numerical credibility. Reliable solutions also require grid- or collocation-point independence, residual assessment, far-field truncation tests, benchmark comparisons, branch-continuation and stability analyses where multiple solutions occur and, whenever feasible, validation against experiments or independent high-fidelity simulations. Advanced nanofluids may improve heat transfer, but the reported gains are strongly model-dependent and may be offset by increased viscosity, wall shear, pressure-drop demands, entropy generation, suspension-instability constraints and uncertainty in thermophysical property correlations. Originality/value Unlike conventional chronological surveys, this review offers a unified, mechanism-based and numerically rigorous synthesis of mixed convection over slender cylinders. It introduces a regime-aware framework that reconciles apparently conflicting transport trends by linking them to governing physical mechanisms, modelling assumptions, boundary conditions and computational practices. The framework also evaluates thermal enhancement against hydrodynamic penalties, and against physical realism, reproducibility and validation, thereby providing a robust basis for comparing existing studies and for developing performance-balanced models for slender-cylinder transport systems.

International Journal of Numerical Methods for Heat &amp Fluid Flow
University of Johannesburg (ZA), KLE Technological University (IN)
Nanofluid Flow and Heat Transfer
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon