“Wait… who said that”? How message source and appeal type shape pro-environmental behavior

Purpose This study aims to investigate why normative appeals produce inconsistent effects on pro-environmental behavior (PEB). The authors propose that existing appeal-centric accounts overlook the influence of the social identity of the message source. The authors aim to examine how source categorization (ingroup, regular outgroup, extreme outgroup) interacts with appeal type (normative versus generic) to shape PEB intentions, with trust and psychological threat as potential mediating mechanisms. Design/methodology/approach Study 1 (n = 300) was a survey designed to examine the role of trust and threat in shaping PEB intentions. Studies 2 (n = 321) and 3 (n = 373) used 2 (appeal type: normative versus generic) × 2 (social categorization of message source: ingroup versus outgroup) between-subjects experiments to assess the moderating role of message source. Findings Study 1 showed that more normative language was associated with lower trust, greater threat and lower PEB, with indirect relationships through both trust and threat. Studies 2 and 3 revealed that the effectiveness of normative appeals is contingent on how message source is socially categorized (ingroup, regular outgroup, extreme outgroup). While appeals from a regular outgroup (versus ingroup) do not change PEB, messages delivered by an extreme outgroup lower it. Normative (versus generic) appeals from an ingroup elicit less trust. These trust differences are muted when the sender is a regular outgroup and the pattern reverses when the source is an extreme outgroup. Threat effects were inconsistent whereby normative (versus generic) appeals increased threat only for ingroup sources, and extreme outgroups elicited higher threat overall. Originality/value This research advances social marketing theory in three ways. First, it challenges appeal-centric accounts of normative messaging by demonstrating that source categorization is a critical and previously overlooked determinant of normative appeal effectiveness. Second, it reveals that source categorization does not operate linearly on message processing. Third, by extending the analysis to AI-driven, nonhuman sources, it connects normative appeal theory to the growing prevalence of AI-mediated communication in behavior-change contexts.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Journal of Social Marketing
Published
2026-11-16
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1108/jsocm-12-2025-0383
Primary Topic
Pro-Environmental Behavior and Attitudes
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

“Wait… who said that”? How message source and appeal type shape pro-environmental behavior

Narmin Tartila Banu, Lindsay McShane
1 links
Journal of Social Marketing
Pro-Environmental Behavior and Attitudes
article

“Wait… who said that”? How message source and appeal type shape pro-environmental behavior

Narmin Tartila Banu, Lindsay McShane
article en

Abstract

Purpose This study aims to investigate why normative appeals produce inconsistent effects on pro-environmental behavior (PEB). The authors propose that existing appeal-centric accounts overlook the influence of the social identity of the message source. The authors aim to examine how source categorization (ingroup, regular outgroup, extreme outgroup) interacts with appeal type (normative versus generic) to shape PEB intentions, with trust and psychological threat as potential mediating mechanisms. Design/methodology/approach Study 1 (n = 300) was a survey designed to examine the role of trust and threat in shaping PEB intentions. Studies 2 (n = 321) and 3 (n = 373) used 2 (appeal type: normative versus generic) × 2 (social categorization of message source: ingroup versus outgroup) between-subjects experiments to assess the moderating role of message source. Findings Study 1 showed that more normative language was associated with lower trust, greater threat and lower PEB, with indirect relationships through both trust and threat. Studies 2 and 3 revealed that the effectiveness of normative appeals is contingent on how message source is socially categorized (ingroup, regular outgroup, extreme outgroup). While appeals from a regular outgroup (versus ingroup) do not change PEB, messages delivered by an extreme outgroup lower it. Normative (versus generic) appeals from an ingroup elicit less trust. These trust differences are muted when the sender is a regular outgroup and the pattern reverses when the source is an extreme outgroup. Threat effects were inconsistent whereby normative (versus generic) appeals increased threat only for ingroup sources, and extreme outgroups elicited higher threat overall. Originality/value This research advances social marketing theory in three ways. First, it challenges appeal-centric accounts of normative messaging by demonstrating that source categorization is a critical and previously overlooked determinant of normative appeal effectiveness. Second, it reveals that source categorization does not operate linearly on message processing. Third, by extending the analysis to AI-driven, nonhuman sources, it connects normative appeal theory to the growing prevalence of AI-mediated communication in behavior-change contexts.

Journal of Social Marketing
University of Northern Iowa (US), Carleton University (CA)
Pro-Environmental Behavior and Attitudes
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon