Pre-registration and result (17 Nov 2026): a high UCB exploration constant does not reduce premature convergence in a 14-bus generator-bidding game, under a criterion that saturates
Version 2. Version 1 held the protocol and code alone and was published before the confirmatory run returned; this version adds the result, so the deposit order is part of the record. CLAUSE: UCB with kappa = 1.0 has a nonzero premature-convergence rate at least as high as low-exploration UCB with kappa = 0.1, under identical 200-round budgets (IEEE 14-bus, DC clearing, finite bid grids, 100 seeded runs). VERDICT: FALSIFIED by the registered rule. Premature-convergence rate was 0.98 at kappa = 1.0 and 0.98 at kappa = 0.1 (kappa = 0 control: 0.99); discordant pairs 1 versus 1; one-sided exact McNemar p = 0.75. IMPORTANT LIMIT: the row's own criterion is saturated in this market. It fires on 98-99 percent of runs whatever kappa is, and the detector control passed by a single run (0.99 versus 0.98). The result therefore shows that the stated benefit cannot be shown under the stated criterion here, not that exploration is irrelevant to convergence quality. The criterion was not altered. DESCRIPTIVE ONLY, NOT TESTED: mean best-response regret falls from 132.7 (kappa = 0) to 111.1 (kappa = 0.1) to 86.2 (kappa = 1.0); the bus-2 generator is the one agent whose rate drops clearly at kappa = 1.0 (0.34 to 0.21). Both are single-run readings and may be noise. CONTROLS: clearing, exhaustive regret instrument and seed pairing passed; the detector control passed narrowly. SCOPE: canonical MATPOWER case14 run as published, which is UNCONGESTED (every branch rateA = 0), five generators, 21-point bid grid, grid-aggregated GP-UCB, 200 rounds, two kappa values. Nothing here transfers to congested networks, other learners or real markets.
Authors
- John Goodman (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0008-4080-8043)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-16
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24293494
- Primary Topic
- Electric Power System Optimization
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00