Methodological and evidentiary concerns regarding the Danish recommendations for chiropractic care of infants

Abstract Background Overgaard et al. recently published national recommendations for history taking, examination and clinical management of infants in Danish chiropractic practice. Such recommendations can shape clinical practice, education and regulation, so their development methods and evidentiary basis warrant scrutiny. This letter examines the recommendations against established standards for consensus methodology and guideline development, and against the existing pediatric chiropractic literature. Main body We raise five concerns. First, describing the recommendations as “consensus-based” is difficult to reconcile with the reported method of gathering clinical perspectives, which did not follow a formal consensus technique such as the Delphi or RAND/UCLA method; “expert-informed” would describe the process more accurately. Second, the claim of novelty overlooks a published Delphi-derived best-practice guideline for pediatric chiropractic care whose domains overlap with the Danish recommendations. Third, the force recommendations rely on tensile-strength extrapolations that are not validated clinical safety thresholds, express force as a percentage of an unspecified adult reference, cannot be measured by chiropractors during treatment, and leave infants aged 4 weeks to 2 months without guidance. Clinical measurements of chiropractic forces in children support lower forces for infants but do not validate percentage-based thresholds. Fourth, the recommendations detail the exclusion of serious pathology but do not specify the positive examination findings that justify manual intervention or how these findings inform clinical decisions. Fifth, the authors report neither a systematic literature review nor a formal assessment of evidence certainty or recommendation strength; adherence to the RIGHT reporting statement cannot substitute for systematic evidence synthesis or an evidence-to-recommendation framework such as GRADE. Conclusions The Danish recommendations address an important area of practice, but their consensus claim, novelty, force guidance, clinical indications and evidence base require revision or qualification. Aligning future recommendations with formal consensus methods, systematic evidence synthesis and explicit grading of recommendations would strengthen their credibility and support safe, evidence-informed chiropractic care of infants.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Chiropractic & Manual Therapies
Published
2026-11-16
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1186/s12998-026-00686-4
Primary Topic
Clinical practice guidelines implementation
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Methodological and evidentiary concerns regarding the Danish recommendations for chiropractic care of infants

Justin Ohm, Joel Alcantara
Chiropractic & Manual Therapies
Clinical practice guidelines implementation
article

Methodological and evidentiary concerns regarding the Danish recommendations for chiropractic care of infants

Justin Ohm, Joel Alcantara
article en

Abstract

Abstract Background Overgaard et al. recently published national recommendations for history taking, examination and clinical management of infants in Danish chiropractic practice. Such recommendations can shape clinical practice, education and regulation, so their development methods and evidentiary basis warrant scrutiny. This letter examines the recommendations against established standards for consensus methodology and guideline development, and against the existing pediatric chiropractic literature. Main body We raise five concerns. First, describing the recommendations as “consensus-based” is difficult to reconcile with the reported method of gathering clinical perspectives, which did not follow a formal consensus technique such as the Delphi or RAND/UCLA method; “expert-informed” would describe the process more accurately. Second, the claim of novelty overlooks a published Delphi-derived best-practice guideline for pediatric chiropractic care whose domains overlap with the Danish recommendations. Third, the force recommendations rely on tensile-strength extrapolations that are not validated clinical safety thresholds, express force as a percentage of an unspecified adult reference, cannot be measured by chiropractors during treatment, and leave infants aged 4 weeks to 2 months without guidance. Clinical measurements of chiropractic forces in children support lower forces for infants but do not validate percentage-based thresholds. Fourth, the recommendations detail the exclusion of serious pathology but do not specify the positive examination findings that justify manual intervention or how these findings inform clinical decisions. Fifth, the authors report neither a systematic literature review nor a formal assessment of evidence certainty or recommendation strength; adherence to the RIGHT reporting statement cannot substitute for systematic evidence synthesis or an evidence-to-recommendation framework such as GRADE. Conclusions The Danish recommendations address an important area of practice, but their consensus claim, novelty, force guidance, clinical indications and evidence base require revision or qualification. Aligning future recommendations with formal consensus methods, systematic evidence synthesis and explicit grading of recommendations would strengthen their credibility and support safe, evidence-informed chiropractic care of infants.

Chiropractic & Manual TherapiesVol. 34(1)
Clinical practice guidelines implementation
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon