The "Third-Year Effect" in Humanistic Competency: Latent Profile Analysis and Implications for Precision Medical Education in Residency Training

Abstract Background Precision medical education advocates moving beyond aggregate population-level analyses to understand individual learner heterogeneity. Clinical educators frequently observe a paradox: trainees gain technical proficiency while experiencing affective exhaustion. However, whether clinical master's candidates exhibit distinct humanistic competency profiles, and how these profiles shift across residency training years, remains insufficiently understood. Methods This cross-sectional study applied Latent Profile Analysis (LPA) to 448 clinical master's candidates undergoing standardized residency training across six medical schools in a Chinese province, after excluding four extreme outliers (mean Z-score < -2.5). Seven indicators spanning cognitive, reflective, affective, and ethical domains were modeled: narrative competence; three reflective capacity tiers (habitual action, reflection, critical reflection); empathy (measured via Interpersonal Reactivity Index); professionalism; and clinical ethical cognition. Cross-tabulation and chi-square tests examined profile distribution across training cohorts. Results Three latent profiles emerged with perfect classification entropy (1.000): Initial Development (10.5%), Steady Development (87.1%), and Advanced Development (2.5%). Profile membership significantly associated with training seniority (χ²=6.607, p = 0.037): Initial Development proportion more than doubled from 6.0% in junior cohort (Years 1) to 13.2% in senior cohort (Year2-3), representing a 2.2-fold risk elevation, while Steady Development contracted from 92.3% to 83.9%. Detailed three-year analysis revealed progressive erosion: 6.0% (Year 1) → 11.7% (Year 2) → 14.8% (Year 3). Dual-identity pressure (DIP)—conflict between clinical duties and academic requirements—was significantly elevated in senior trainees (M = 66.58 vs. 62.30, p = 0.011) and negatively correlated with empathy (r=-0.105, p = 0.027), suggesting resource depletion underlies third-year humanistic erosion. Conclusions Humanistic competency exhibits substantial heterogeneity with a significant "third-year effect" characterized by cumulative attrition rather than abrupt shock. This erosion reflects depletion-driven coping under dual-identity strain rather than moral deficiency. Medical education should adopt precision-based approaches: universal baseline training coupled with profile-tailored micro-interventions for vulnerable trainees (13.2% concentrated in Initial Development during Year 3), embedded within daily workflows to safeguard affective engagement when DIP peaks and humanistic competence becomes a discretionary resource trainees sacrifice for survival.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Research Square
Published
2026-11-16
DOI
https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-11314137/v1
Primary Topic
Innovations in Medical Education
Type
preprint

Funders

Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

The "Third-Year Effect" in Humanistic Competency: Latent Profile Analysis and Implications for Precision Medical Education in Residency Training

Xiaolan Liu, Zhengshuai Lv, Hua Jiang, Zhen Su
3 links
Research Square
Innovations in Medical Education
preprint

The "Third-Year Effect" in Humanistic Competency: Latent Profile Analysis and Implications for Precision Medical Education in Residency Training

Xiaolan Liu, Zhengshuai Lv, Hua Jiang, Zhen Su
preprint en

Abstract

Abstract Background Precision medical education advocates moving beyond aggregate population-level analyses to understand individual learner heterogeneity. Clinical educators frequently observe a paradox: trainees gain technical proficiency while experiencing affective exhaustion. However, whether clinical master's candidates exhibit distinct humanistic competency profiles, and how these profiles shift across residency training years, remains insufficiently understood. Methods This cross-sectional study applied Latent Profile Analysis (LPA) to 448 clinical master's candidates undergoing standardized residency training across six medical schools in a Chinese province, after excluding four extreme outliers (mean Z-score < -2.5). Seven indicators spanning cognitive, reflective, affective, and ethical domains were modeled: narrative competence; three reflective capacity tiers (habitual action, reflection, critical reflection); empathy (measured via Interpersonal Reactivity Index); professionalism; and clinical ethical cognition. Cross-tabulation and chi-square tests examined profile distribution across training cohorts. Results Three latent profiles emerged with perfect classification entropy (1.000): Initial Development (10.5%), Steady Development (87.1%), and Advanced Development (2.5%). Profile membership significantly associated with training seniority (χ²=6.607, p = 0.037): Initial Development proportion more than doubled from 6.0% in junior cohort (Years 1) to 13.2% in senior cohort (Year2-3), representing a 2.2-fold risk elevation, while Steady Development contracted from 92.3% to 83.9%. Detailed three-year analysis revealed progressive erosion: 6.0% (Year 1) → 11.7% (Year 2) → 14.8% (Year 3). Dual-identity pressure (DIP)—conflict between clinical duties and academic requirements—was significantly elevated in senior trainees (M = 66.58 vs. 62.30, p = 0.011) and negatively correlated with empathy (r=-0.105, p = 0.027), suggesting resource depletion underlies third-year humanistic erosion. Conclusions Humanistic competency exhibits substantial heterogeneity with a significant "third-year effect" characterized by cumulative attrition rather than abrupt shock. This erosion reflects depletion-driven coping under dual-identity strain rather than moral deficiency. Medical education should adopt precision-based approaches: universal baseline training coupled with profile-tailored micro-interventions for vulnerable trainees (13.2% concentrated in Initial Development during Year 3), embedded within daily workflows to safeguard affective engagement when DIP peaks and humanistic competence becomes a discretionary resource trainees sacrifice for survival.

Research Square
Liaoning Normal University (CN), Second Affiliated Hospital of Dalian Medical University (CN), First Affiliated Hospital of Dalian Medical University (CN)
Ministry of Education of the People's Republic of China, Dalian University of Technology, China Medical University, Dalian Medical University
Quality education, Good health and well-being
Innovations in Medical Education
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon