SAE Relation Theory Special Paper: Positive-Sum, Unsought / SAE 关系论专论:恰为正和
This paper reads where the sum in a relation can fall. There are two kinds of sum. Payoff positive-sum lies on the payoff table: to speak of it, one first states the baseline of comparison, which gains and costs are counted, and the single scale on which their change is recorded; it can be reckoned, and it can be sought. Ontological positive-sum is the legislative subjectivity of both ends becoming more active: it does not lie on the payoff table, cannot be reckoned, and is not summed. The positive-sum, unsought, that this paper speaks of is ontological positive-sum. The three cases, divided by the number of ends headed in the 15DD direction, are a stipulation at the object layer, not three kinds of people and not three kinds of relation; 15DD and 14DD here are stances, not labels, and the layer is recorded by a single operation. In dealings where both ends read the other only as an item in their own tables, the payoff layer goes with the game: a zero-sum game lands at zero-sum, a standard one-shot prisoner's dilemma lands in the cell where both are worse off than under joint cooperation, and a game with a positive-sum cell in it can land at payoff positive-sum. The ontological positive-sum this paper reads cannot be read there: its antecedent is that at least one end recognizes the other as an end too. This paper does not on that account judge that nothing at all grew on that occasion. Among such dealings, those that contend for recognition as a finite resource are zero-sum at the ontological layer; those that oppose each other until both parties' subjectivity is consumed are negative-sum at the ontological layer. Between dealings in the 14DD direction and in the 15DD direction, the difference lies not in whether there is payoff but in where the sum can fall: payoff is not enough: growth is necessary for ontological positive-sum, but growth alone is not sufficient. When one end is headed in the 15DD direction and the other leans toward 14DD, ontological positive-sum appears in the shape of cultivation. Cultivation carried out means that this end took on the direction of cultivation, and that his act also actually opened the conditions for the other's own forming, avowing and revising; once cultivation has been carried out, this end gains, and the gain lies in the exercise of the legislative activity of recognizing the other as an end, without waiting for anything to come back from the other, and without waiting for the other to grow. Where the other's own law has grown too, it is read as ontological positive-sum; where it has not, it is recorded as it is. Neither side's gain can be obtained by seeking it: producing and checking a result against a standard fixed in advance yields the result the standard records, and cannot stand in for the actual unfolding of legislative activity. So ontological positive-sum is read only in looking back: where it can be read, it came unsought; where it cannot, it is recorded as it is. Whether to make a cultivative intervention toward the other is first assessed as Cultivation Theory has it, and what is judged is conditions, not an expected sum. To say that a stretch of dealings has ontological positive-sum does not offset the account of harm. This paper borrows the phrase "purposiveness without purpose" on the relation side and states its limits; it interfaces with Kant, Smith, von Neumann and Morgenstern, and the Laozi. It does not prove that 15DD pays at the payoff layer, does not prove that 14DD must lose at the payoff layer, does not prove that one ought to treat people from 15DD, and does not prove that cultivation is bound to succeed. 这一篇读关系里的和能落到哪里。和有两种。收益正和在收益表上:说它,先说明比较基准、计入哪些所得与代价,用同一尺度记其变化;它可以计算,也可以求。本体正和是两端的立法主体性更活跃:它不在收益表上,不可计算,不加总。这一篇说的恰为正和,是本体正和。三种情形按在 15DD 方向上的端数分,是对象层的设定,不是三类人,也不是三类关系;15DD、14DD 在这里是姿态,不是标签,层按一次运作记。 两端都只把对方读作自己表里一项的来往,收益层随局走:零和的局落在零和,标准的一次囚徒困境落到双方都不如共同合作的那一格,局里有正和一格的,可以落到收益正和。这一篇所读的本体正和读不到这里:它的前件是至少一端认对方也是目的。这一篇不因此判这一次没有任何成长。其中把承认当作有限的资源去争的,本体层上是零和;对抗到双方的主体性都被消耗的,本体层上是负和。14DD 与 15DD 方向的来往,区别不在有没有收益,在和能落到哪里:有收益还不够,有成长才是本体正和。 一端在 15DD 方向上、另一端偏 14DD 时,本体正和以涵育的样子出现。涵育做出了,指这一端承担了涵育的方向,他的作为也实际打开了对方自己形成、认领与修订的条件;涵育做出了,这一端就有所得,所得落在承认对方为目的这项立法活动的实行,不等对方回过来给什么,也不等对方长成。对方自己的法也长开了的,读作本体正和;没有长开的,照实记。两边的所得都求不来:照预定的标准制作与验收,得到的是标准所登记的结果,替不了立法活动的实际展开。所以本体正和只在回看里读:读得出的,是恰;读不出的,照实记。要不要对对方作涵育性的介入,照涵育论先评估,判的是条件,不是预期的和。说一段来往有本体正和,不抵伤害的账。 这一篇在关系侧借用「非目的性的合目的性」一语,写明它的限度;与康德、斯密、冯·诺伊曼与摩根斯特恩、《老子》对接。它不证明 15DD 在收益上划算,不证明 14DD 在收益上必输,不证明应当以 15DD 待人,也不证明涵育必成。
Authors
- Han Qin (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0009-9583-0018)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-16
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24270580
- Primary Topic
- Game Theory and Applications
- Type
- preprint