The descriptive turn in the study of the boundaries of science: the concept of "Boundary Work"

Relevance . The philosophical search for a universal solution to the demarcation problem has faced fundamental difficulties due to the historical and disciplinary heterogeneity of scientific knowledge. At the same time, the local distinction between the scientific and non-scientific regularly occurs in public, legal, and academic spheres. The resulting gap between theory and real practice highlights the relevance of the descriptive turn, which shifts the focus to how social actors themselves construct and defend the boundaries of science across various sociocultural contexts. The purpose is to examine the specifics of the descriptive approach to the boundaries of science (using T. Gieryn’s concept of "boundary work" as an example) and to outline the potential for its further development. Objectives : to reconstruct the prerequisites of the descriptive turn in demarcation studies; to trace the genesis of the "boundary work" concept within STS and its main theoretical modifications; to justify the feasibility of deepening this approach by studying the linguistic properties of the demarcation lexicon ("science"/"pseudoscience", "scientist"/"pseudoscientist", etc.). Methodology . The study is based on a theoretical analysis of metascientific texts on the boundaries of science. The systematization of the analytical levels of "boundary work" relies on the sociological model of distinguishing between symbolic and social boundaries (M. Lamont, V. Molnár). Empirical data on demarcation word usage are interpreted using the heuristics of meta-axiological non-cognitivism. Results . The study demonstrates how various versions of the "boundary work" concept methodologically complement each other, revealing different aspects of demarcation practices: namely, their rhetorical organization (A. Holmquest), macrosociological conditioning (D. Fisher), and pluralistic nature (D. Hess). It is proposed to extend this spectrum by introducing a semantic-pragmatic analysis of demarcation concepts as specific evaluativedescriptive categories expressing the regulative attitudes of cognitive activity. Conclusions . The complexity and diversity of demarcation practices drive the development of the descriptive approach turn as an open, expanding research program. An interdisciplinary synthesis of analytical tools ‒ from macrosociology to meta-axiology ‒ facilitates a transition from rigid, universalist schemas toward a flexible understanding of the real processes of drawing the boundaries of science.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Proceedings of the Southwest State University Series Economics Sociology and Management
Published
2026-11-16
DOI
https://doi.org/10.21869/2223-1552-2026-16-4-244-257
Primary Topic
Philosophy of Biology and Scientific Explanation
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

The descriptive turn in the study of the boundaries of science: the concept of "Boundary Work"

Vladislav V. Stasenko
Proceedings of the Southwest State University Series Economics Sociology and Management
Philosophy of Biology and Scientific Explanation
article

The descriptive turn in the study of the boundaries of science: the concept of "Boundary Work"

Vladislav V. Stasenko
article en

Abstract

Relevance . The philosophical search for a universal solution to the demarcation problem has faced fundamental difficulties due to the historical and disciplinary heterogeneity of scientific knowledge. At the same time, the local distinction between the scientific and non-scientific regularly occurs in public, legal, and academic spheres. The resulting gap between theory and real practice highlights the relevance of the descriptive turn, which shifts the focus to how social actors themselves construct and defend the boundaries of science across various sociocultural contexts. The purpose is to examine the specifics of the descriptive approach to the boundaries of science (using T. Gieryn’s concept of "boundary work" as an example) and to outline the potential for its further development. Objectives : to reconstruct the prerequisites of the descriptive turn in demarcation studies; to trace the genesis of the "boundary work" concept within STS and its main theoretical modifications; to justify the feasibility of deepening this approach by studying the linguistic properties of the demarcation lexicon ("science"/"pseudoscience", "scientist"/"pseudoscientist", etc.). Methodology . The study is based on a theoretical analysis of metascientific texts on the boundaries of science. The systematization of the analytical levels of "boundary work" relies on the sociological model of distinguishing between symbolic and social boundaries (M. Lamont, V. Molnár). Empirical data on demarcation word usage are interpreted using the heuristics of meta-axiological non-cognitivism. Results . The study demonstrates how various versions of the "boundary work" concept methodologically complement each other, revealing different aspects of demarcation practices: namely, their rhetorical organization (A. Holmquest), macrosociological conditioning (D. Fisher), and pluralistic nature (D. Hess). It is proposed to extend this spectrum by introducing a semantic-pragmatic analysis of demarcation concepts as specific evaluativedescriptive categories expressing the regulative attitudes of cognitive activity. Conclusions . The complexity and diversity of demarcation practices drive the development of the descriptive approach turn as an open, expanding research program. An interdisciplinary synthesis of analytical tools ‒ from macrosociology to meta-axiology ‒ facilitates a transition from rigid, universalist schemas toward a flexible understanding of the real processes of drawing the boundaries of science.

Proceedings of the Southwest State University Series Economics Sociology and ManagementVol. 16(4)
Russian Academy of Sciences (RU), Institute of Scientific Information on Social Sciences (RU), S.I. Vavilov Institute for the History of Science and Technology (RU)
Philosophy of Biology and Scientific Explanation
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon