Moving run time from fast trips to slow ones: a pre-registered test on MBTA bus schedules

Objective. Bus agencies set scheduled run times in advance; for its headway-managed trips, the MBTA treats a trip as not on time at its last stop when its run time is more than 120% of its scheduled run time. I ask whether moving scheduled run-time hours toward slow trips, with total hours unchanged, lowers failures. Data. Public MBTA bus arrival and departure data. A pre-registered rule sets each route, direction, terminal pair and start-hour budget from its April to June 2026 average run time, scaled to equal the published schedule's hours, and was scored once on 64 held-out July to September 2026 weekdays (683,346 scored trips). Findings. On paper (a schedule simulation: actual run times are held fixed and only the budgets change), the share of trips failing a 120% run-time test (the MBTA's headway-trip test, applied here to all trips) fell from 13.10% to 10.86% (-2.24 percentage points; 95% interval -3.62 to -0.97). Five caveats limit this. The gain vanishes when hours must stay equal within each route, direction and period (+0.12). It is inconclusive in September 2026, which mixes 4 summer-schedule weekdays with 17 after the MBTA's fall schedule change (-0.37; 95% interval -1.87 to +0.93). And on the headway-standard trips that the MBTA's test actually governs it is inconclusive (-1.19; 95% interval -3.65 to +0.88). Training on July to September 2025 instead gives -1.00 (95% interval -2.41 to +0.39), so part of the gain may come from fresher data. And 15.7% of test trips lacked an end time and were not scored. The cost of moving hours was not measured. What is new. A network-wide, equal-hours re-score against the 120% test on a held-out, pre-registered quarter. Practical use. A screening check for schedule planners, not evidence that the MBTA should change its schedules.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-16
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24280937
Primary Topic
Transportation Planning and Optimization
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

Moving run time from fast trips to slow ones: a pre-registered test on MBTA bus schedules

Jayden Ling
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Transportation Planning and Optimization
preprint

Moving run time from fast trips to slow ones: a pre-registered test on MBTA bus schedules

Jayden Ling
preprint en

Abstract

Objective. Bus agencies set scheduled run times in advance; for its headway-managed trips, the MBTA treats a trip as not on time at its last stop when its run time is more than 120% of its scheduled run time. I ask whether moving scheduled run-time hours toward slow trips, with total hours unchanged, lowers failures. Data. Public MBTA bus arrival and departure data. A pre-registered rule sets each route, direction, terminal pair and start-hour budget from its April to June 2026 average run time, scaled to equal the published schedule's hours, and was scored once on 64 held-out July to September 2026 weekdays (683,346 scored trips). Findings. On paper (a schedule simulation: actual run times are held fixed and only the budgets change), the share of trips failing a 120% run-time test (the MBTA's headway-trip test, applied here to all trips) fell from 13.10% to 10.86% (-2.24 percentage points; 95% interval -3.62 to -0.97). Five caveats limit this. The gain vanishes when hours must stay equal within each route, direction and period (+0.12). It is inconclusive in September 2026, which mixes 4 summer-schedule weekdays with 17 after the MBTA's fall schedule change (-0.37; 95% interval -1.87 to +0.93). And on the headway-standard trips that the MBTA's test actually governs it is inconclusive (-1.19; 95% interval -3.65 to +0.88). Training on July to September 2025 instead gives -1.00 (95% interval -2.41 to +0.39), so part of the gain may come from fresher data. And 15.7% of test trips lacked an end time and were not scored. The cost of moving hours was not measured. What is new. A network-wide, equal-hours re-score against the 120% test on a held-out, pre-registered quarter. Practical use. A screening check for schedule planners, not evidence that the MBTA should change its schedules.

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Sustainable cities and communities
Transportation Planning and Optimization
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon