Benchmarking Four Digital Twin Implementations: An Evidence-Based Assessment Using the Digital Twin Maturity Model

Digital twin technologies are increasingly used to support asset management, infrastructure monitoring and operational decision-making. These applications are increasingly central to smart cities, where digital twins of buildings and infrastructure are the building blocks of city-scale digital twins. However, the term digital twin is applied inconsistently across platforms, which differ widely in data integration, automation, analytical and visualisation capability; this has left industry and researchers asking what a given digital twin can really do. This study develops and applies a practical, implementation-based methodology for evaluating the maturity of digital twin frameworks. Four frameworks, Autodesk Tandem, OpenTwins, Bentley iTwin and AWS IoT TwinMaker, were selected because they represent different approaches to development, features, licensing and maturity. A common case study was implemented on each, using a Building Information Model and a live Internet of Things stream of temperature and humidity published by a Raspberry Pi 5, and each implementation was assessed against the maturity aspects of ISO/IEC 30186:2025. Five common monitoring tasks and an evidence-based item-level scoring procedure were used to distinguish implemented functionality from features described only in documentation. This study documents framework selection, implementation workflows, data integration methods and practical limitations to reproducibility, including differing data update intervals. All four implementations reached Level 2 in convergence, while other maturity aspects varied; AWS IoT TwinMaker additionally achieved Level 2 in trustworthiness. A one-hour AWS observation retained 60 of 60 expected samples for each measured variable, demonstrating data continuity rather than calibrated sensor accuracy. None of the tested implementations demonstrated prediction, bidirectional control or autonomous inter-twin coordination. The results show that maturity should be evaluated against implemented functionality and interpreted alongside practical considerations such as usability, data ownership and required expertise. For smart cities, the study gives local governments, utilities and asset owners a reproducible basis for selecting digital twin platforms for urban buildings and infrastructure and identifies the capabilities still needed to progress towards federated, city-scale digital twins.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Smart Cities
Published
2026-11-16
DOI
https://doi.org/10.3390/smartcities9110196
Primary Topic
Digital Transformation in Industry
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Benchmarking Four Digital Twin Implementations: An Evidence-Based Assessment Using the Digital Twin Maturity Model

Zahra Gharineiat, Kye Rodenberg
1 links
Smart Cities
Digital Transformation in Industry
article

Benchmarking Four Digital Twin Implementations: An Evidence-Based Assessment Using the Digital Twin Maturity Model

Zahra Gharineiat, Kye Rodenberg
article en

Abstract

Digital twin technologies are increasingly used to support asset management, infrastructure monitoring and operational decision-making. These applications are increasingly central to smart cities, where digital twins of buildings and infrastructure are the building blocks of city-scale digital twins. However, the term digital twin is applied inconsistently across platforms, which differ widely in data integration, automation, analytical and visualisation capability; this has left industry and researchers asking what a given digital twin can really do. This study develops and applies a practical, implementation-based methodology for evaluating the maturity of digital twin frameworks. Four frameworks, Autodesk Tandem, OpenTwins, Bentley iTwin and AWS IoT TwinMaker, were selected because they represent different approaches to development, features, licensing and maturity. A common case study was implemented on each, using a Building Information Model and a live Internet of Things stream of temperature and humidity published by a Raspberry Pi 5, and each implementation was assessed against the maturity aspects of ISO/IEC 30186:2025. Five common monitoring tasks and an evidence-based item-level scoring procedure were used to distinguish implemented functionality from features described only in documentation. This study documents framework selection, implementation workflows, data integration methods and practical limitations to reproducibility, including differing data update intervals. All four implementations reached Level 2 in convergence, while other maturity aspects varied; AWS IoT TwinMaker additionally achieved Level 2 in trustworthiness. A one-hour AWS observation retained 60 of 60 expected samples for each measured variable, demonstrating data continuity rather than calibrated sensor accuracy. None of the tested implementations demonstrated prediction, bidirectional control or autonomous inter-twin coordination. The results show that maturity should be evaluated against implemented functionality and interpreted alongside practical considerations such as usability, data ownership and required expertise. For smart cities, the study gives local governments, utilities and asset owners a reproducible basis for selecting digital twin platforms for urban buildings and infrastructure and identifies the capabilities still needed to progress towards federated, city-scale digital twins.

Smart CitiesVol. 9(11)
University of Southern Queensland (AU)
Industry, innovation and infrastructure, Sustainable cities and communities
Digital Transformation in Industry
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon