Nutrient profiles govern organic-mineral fertilizer interactions on maize yield in Kenya

Abstract Co-applying mineral and organic nutrient inputs is widely recommended to enhance maize yields and soil fertility in sub-Saharan Africa. However, long-term on-farm evaluations that assess how input combinations, baseline soil fertility, and climatic conditions affect yield trajectories remain scarce. Over 10 seasons (5 years), this study investigated maize yield and agronomic nitrogen- and phosphorus use efficiencies (AEN; AEP) across 20 farms in two Kenyan counties (Vihiga and Siaya, ~ 48% and 64% clay content, respectively), comparing high- and low-fertility fields. Treatments evaluated local versus improved maize varieties (IR maize) and the addition of multi-component fertilizer (MCF), farmyard manure, and calcium-ammonium-nitrate (CAN) top-dressing in an additive split-plot design (only to IR maize). While combining all three inputs (MCF, manure, and CAN) achieved the highest overall yields, no treatment could significantly increase yields over time, highlighting the challenge of achieving positive temporal trends in continuous maize monoculture at realistic input rates. A significant negative interaction between MCF and manure negated ~ 70% of manure’s positive effect, potentially due to overlapping nutrient profiles. MCF significantly outperformed manure, showing higher yields and AEN values (39–43 kg yield kg − 1 N); AEP was highest under manure combined with CAN (52–62 kg yield kg − 1 P). CAN provided a modest yield benefit (+ 141 kg ha − 1 season − 1 ), showing no negative interactions with MCF or manure. Our findings suggest that effective plant nutrition in smallholder systems should focus on complementing nutrient profiles and consider both current yield and yield trajectories.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Research Square
Published
2026-11-16
DOI
https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-11512301/v1
Primary Topic
Agricultural Science and Fertilization
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

Nutrient profiles govern organic-mineral fertilizer interactions on maize yield in Kenya

Bernard Vanlauwe, Moritz Laub, Johan Six, Joyce Mutai et al.
1 links
Research Square
Agricultural Science and Fertilization
preprint

Nutrient profiles govern organic-mineral fertilizer interactions on maize yield in Kenya

Bernard Vanlauwe, Moritz Laub, Johan Six, Joyce Mutai, Laban Nyambega
preprint en

Abstract

Abstract Co-applying mineral and organic nutrient inputs is widely recommended to enhance maize yields and soil fertility in sub-Saharan Africa. However, long-term on-farm evaluations that assess how input combinations, baseline soil fertility, and climatic conditions affect yield trajectories remain scarce. Over 10 seasons (5 years), this study investigated maize yield and agronomic nitrogen- and phosphorus use efficiencies (AEN; AEP) across 20 farms in two Kenyan counties (Vihiga and Siaya, ~ 48% and 64% clay content, respectively), comparing high- and low-fertility fields. Treatments evaluated local versus improved maize varieties (IR maize) and the addition of multi-component fertilizer (MCF), farmyard manure, and calcium-ammonium-nitrate (CAN) top-dressing in an additive split-plot design (only to IR maize). While combining all three inputs (MCF, manure, and CAN) achieved the highest overall yields, no treatment could significantly increase yields over time, highlighting the challenge of achieving positive temporal trends in continuous maize monoculture at realistic input rates. A significant negative interaction between MCF and manure negated ~ 70% of manure’s positive effect, potentially due to overlapping nutrient profiles. MCF significantly outperformed manure, showing higher yields and AEN values (39–43 kg yield kg − 1 N); AEP was highest under manure combined with CAN (52–62 kg yield kg − 1 P). CAN provided a modest yield benefit (+ 141 kg ha − 1 season − 1 ), showing no negative interactions with MCF or manure. Our findings suggest that effective plant nutrition in smallholder systems should focus on complementing nutrient profiles and consider both current yield and yield trajectories.

Research Square
ETH Zurich (CH), International Institute of Tropical Agriculture (TZ), International Institute of Tropical Agriculture (UG), International Institute of Tropical Agriculture (KE), International Institute of Tropical Agriculture (NG), International Institute of Tropical Agriculture (CM), International Institute of Tropical Agriculture (BJ), International Institute of Tropical Agriculture (NG)
Zero hunger
Agricultural Science and Fertilization
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon