Issues of Categorical Conclusions in Forensic Examinations: Subjectivity behind the Illusion of Scientific Rigor

The article deals with the methodological transformation in modern forensic examination in Western countries. This transformation is triggered by the trend of categorical conclusions’ rejection in forensic examinations (fingerprinting, ballistics, traceology, etc.) when solving the identification tasks in favor of probabilistic approaches, primarily the likelihood ratio (LR). Precedent decisions of Western courts and the PCAST report (2016) are presented to demonstrate that the criticism of this method is based on the insufficient formalization of its scientific validation. The LR approach is considered in detail as a theoretical alternative based on the Bayes’ theorem. Its declared advantages are given: reduced subjectivity, consideration of alternative assumptions (hypotheses) and standardized form of conclusions (ENFSI Guideline). The central thesis of the article is that the introduction of the LR does not eliminate the fundamental problem of subjectivity but transforms it: the key source of uncertainty is the “choice of models” – the final LR dependence on the subjectively selected assumptions, statistical adjustments, distribution of characteristics and interpretation algorithms. It is emphasized that this methodological vulnerability creates an “illusion of mathematical rigor” that masks the subjectivity of interpreting the results of a comparative study. The risks of uncritical adoption of these approaches for the domestic forensic system are also highlighted including the destabilization of methodological integrity.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Theory and Practice of Forensic Science
Published
2026-11-16
DOI
https://doi.org/10.30764/1819-2785-2026-3-93-106
Primary Topic
Legal processes and jurisprudence
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Issues of Categorical Conclusions in Forensic Examinations: Subjectivity behind the Illusion of Scientific Rigor

Кокин Андрей Васильевич
1 links
Theory and Practice of Forensic Science
Legal processes and jurisprudence
article

Issues of Categorical Conclusions in Forensic Examinations: Subjectivity behind the Illusion of Scientific Rigor

Кокин Андрей Васильевич
article en

Abstract

The article deals with the methodological transformation in modern forensic examination in Western countries. This transformation is triggered by the trend of categorical conclusions’ rejection in forensic examinations (fingerprinting, ballistics, traceology, etc.) when solving the identification tasks in favor of probabilistic approaches, primarily the likelihood ratio (LR). Precedent decisions of Western courts and the PCAST report (2016) are presented to demonstrate that the criticism of this method is based on the insufficient formalization of its scientific validation. The LR approach is considered in detail as a theoretical alternative based on the Bayes’ theorem. Its declared advantages are given: reduced subjectivity, consideration of alternative assumptions (hypotheses) and standardized form of conclusions (ENFSI Guideline). The central thesis of the article is that the introduction of the LR does not eliminate the fundamental problem of subjectivity but transforms it: the key source of uncertainty is the “choice of models” – the final LR dependence on the subjectively selected assumptions, statistical adjustments, distribution of characteristics and interpretation algorithms. It is emphasized that this methodological vulnerability creates an “illusion of mathematical rigor” that masks the subjectivity of interpreting the results of a comparative study. The risks of uncritical adoption of these approaches for the domestic forensic system are also highlighted including the destabilization of methodological integrity.

Theory and Practice of Forensic ScienceVol. 21(3)
Russian Federal Centre of Forensic Science of the Ministry of Justice of the Russian Federation (RU), Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation (RU), Moscow University of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia (RU)
Legal processes and jurisprudence
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon