Moral filters: how self-reported moral identity centrality and demographic heterogeneity recast perceived ethical leadership’s deterrence of misconduct

Purpose The study examines whether perceived ethical leadership discourages self-reported unethical behavior, and whether or not this effect is moderated by self-reported moral identity centrality, and furthermore whether there are demographic differences (such as gender, age, job type) in these effects in organizational contexts. Design/methodology/approach Drawing on social learning and social cognitive theories, the authors conceptualize moral identity centrality as the degree to which moral traits are central to an individual’s self-concept and examine its moderating role in shaping how leadership cues translate into ethical conduct. A cross-sectional study of 304 employees (permanent and contractual; ages 18–60 years old) from large oil and gas industry organizations in Pakistan was conducted, followed by confirmatory factor analysis for measure validation and PROCESS Model 1 regressions with the complement of the artificial neural networks (ANN) to investigate the hypotheses. The sensitivity analysis of ANN revealed that ethical leadership is the top predictor (importance = 91.6%) along with job type (83.5%). Findings Ethical leadership is a significant and negative predictor of unethical behavior, and the moral identity significantly strengthens this deterrent effect, revealing a greater “virtuous synergy” at higher levels of moral identity and a weaker or non-significant “saving grace” at lower levels, as well as differences by demographic heterogeneity, with females finding certain violations more severely, and older managers showing greater ethical stringency, and differences in the levels of ethical evaluation in employment status. Originality/value The study reconciles competing “saving grace” vs “virtuous synergy” views by showing that ethical leadership has stronger deterrent effects on employees with greater moral identity, while it also shows that demographic heterogeneity meaningfully reframes ethical judgments.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
International Journal of Ethics and Systems
Published
2026-11-16
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1108/ijoes-11-2025-0680
Primary Topic
Ethics in Business and Education
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Moral filters: how self-reported moral identity centrality and demographic heterogeneity recast perceived ethical leadership’s deterrence of misconduct

Shakira Nazeer, Zeeshan Tanveer, Kamran Khan
International Journal of Ethics and Systems
Ethics in Business and Education
article

Moral filters: how self-reported moral identity centrality and demographic heterogeneity recast perceived ethical leadership’s deterrence of misconduct

Shakira Nazeer, Zeeshan Tanveer, Kamran Khan
article en

Abstract

Purpose The study examines whether perceived ethical leadership discourages self-reported unethical behavior, and whether or not this effect is moderated by self-reported moral identity centrality, and furthermore whether there are demographic differences (such as gender, age, job type) in these effects in organizational contexts. Design/methodology/approach Drawing on social learning and social cognitive theories, the authors conceptualize moral identity centrality as the degree to which moral traits are central to an individual’s self-concept and examine its moderating role in shaping how leadership cues translate into ethical conduct. A cross-sectional study of 304 employees (permanent and contractual; ages 18–60 years old) from large oil and gas industry organizations in Pakistan was conducted, followed by confirmatory factor analysis for measure validation and PROCESS Model 1 regressions with the complement of the artificial neural networks (ANN) to investigate the hypotheses. The sensitivity analysis of ANN revealed that ethical leadership is the top predictor (importance = 91.6%) along with job type (83.5%). Findings Ethical leadership is a significant and negative predictor of unethical behavior, and the moral identity significantly strengthens this deterrent effect, revealing a greater “virtuous synergy” at higher levels of moral identity and a weaker or non-significant “saving grace” at lower levels, as well as differences by demographic heterogeneity, with females finding certain violations more severely, and older managers showing greater ethical stringency, and differences in the levels of ethical evaluation in employment status. Originality/value The study reconciles competing “saving grace” vs “virtuous synergy” views by showing that ethical leadership has stronger deterrent effects on employees with greater moral identity, while it also shows that demographic heterogeneity meaningfully reframes ethical judgments.

International Journal of Ethics and Systems
University of Central Punjab (PK), University of Sialkot (PK), Virtual University of Pakistan (PK)
Peace, justice, and strong institutions
Ethics in Business and Education
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon