Strong at the Center, Fragile at the Periphery: Multi-Tier Evaluation of Effective Vaccine Management in Ghana

Abstract Background Effective vaccine management is vital for safeguarding vaccine potency and attaining high immunization coverage. This study evaluated Ghana’s immunization supply chain using the World Health Organization’s (WHO) Effective Vaccine Management (EVM) framework to identify operational strengths and systemic vulnerabilities. Methods A descriptive cross-sectional study was conducted across nine administrative regions of Ghana, encompassing 17 districts, 18 hospitals, and 68 sub-district facilities (34 health centers and 33 community-based health planning and services [CHPS] compounds). Data were collected from July to August 2024 using the standardized WHO EVM 1.0 tool through structured interviews, observational inspections, and document reviews. Five primary criteria were assessed: temperature control, stock management, vaccine distribution, vaccine management policies, and information systems. At the regional level, two additional criteria (building, equipment, transport and maintenance) were assessed. Performance was benchmarked against the WHO minimum standard threshold of 80%. Results Performance varied markedly across administrative tiers. Regional cold rooms consistently achieved the 80% benchmark across all criteria, except for stock management in the Eastern Region (79%) and distribution in the Eastern (41%) and Volta (64%) Regions. In contrast, operational-level facilities exhibited significant shortfalls. Temperature control compliance dropped to 52% at the lowest-performing facility (Lower Dodowa CHPS), with 5.9% of districts, 27.8% of hospitals, 20.6% of health centers, and 29.4% of CHPS failing to achieve the 80% standard. Stock management was below the benchmark in 23.5% of districts, 27.8% of hospitals, 55.9% of health centers, and 64.7% of CHPS compounds. Distribution targets were unmet by 41.2% of districts, 22.2% of hospitals, 23.5% of health centers, and 29.4% of CHPS compounds. Information systems constituted the most critical vulnerability across primary care facilities, falling below the benchmark in 52.9% of districts, 50.0% of hospitals, 76.5% of health centers, and 88.2% of CHPS compounds. Conclusion Although the central and regional tiers demonstrated robust capacity, vaccine management remains fragile at the subdistrict and primary healthcare facility levels. Targeted interventions are urgently required to upgrade cold chain infrastructure, optimize last-mile logistics, improve stock governance, and enhance health worker capacity for data management to ensure vaccine security and efficacy in Ghana.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Research Square
Published
2026-11-16
DOI
https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-11250767/v1
Primary Topic
Vaccine Coverage and Hesitancy
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

Strong at the Center, Fragile at the Periphery: Multi-Tier Evaluation of Effective Vaccine Management in Ghana

Anita Adjei, Alhassan Ahmed Deedat, Portia Salia, Eric Osei et al.
2 links
Research Square
Vaccine Coverage and Hesitancy
preprint

Strong at the Center, Fragile at the Periphery: Multi-Tier Evaluation of Effective Vaccine Management in Ghana

Anita Adjei, Alhassan Ahmed Deedat, Portia Salia, Eric Osei, Samuel Hinneh, Ernest Asare, Bernice Otoo¹, Stephen Aido¹, David Abbey¹, Prince Hemans Geoffery¹, Mandela Akomisnaba¹, Albert Mensah Gbadago¹, Ato Boateng¹
preprint en

Abstract

Abstract Background Effective vaccine management is vital for safeguarding vaccine potency and attaining high immunization coverage. This study evaluated Ghana’s immunization supply chain using the World Health Organization’s (WHO) Effective Vaccine Management (EVM) framework to identify operational strengths and systemic vulnerabilities. Methods A descriptive cross-sectional study was conducted across nine administrative regions of Ghana, encompassing 17 districts, 18 hospitals, and 68 sub-district facilities (34 health centers and 33 community-based health planning and services [CHPS] compounds). Data were collected from July to August 2024 using the standardized WHO EVM 1.0 tool through structured interviews, observational inspections, and document reviews. Five primary criteria were assessed: temperature control, stock management, vaccine distribution, vaccine management policies, and information systems. At the regional level, two additional criteria (building, equipment, transport and maintenance) were assessed. Performance was benchmarked against the WHO minimum standard threshold of 80%. Results Performance varied markedly across administrative tiers. Regional cold rooms consistently achieved the 80% benchmark across all criteria, except for stock management in the Eastern Region (79%) and distribution in the Eastern (41%) and Volta (64%) Regions. In contrast, operational-level facilities exhibited significant shortfalls. Temperature control compliance dropped to 52% at the lowest-performing facility (Lower Dodowa CHPS), with 5.9% of districts, 27.8% of hospitals, 20.6% of health centers, and 29.4% of CHPS failing to achieve the 80% standard. Stock management was below the benchmark in 23.5% of districts, 27.8% of hospitals, 55.9% of health centers, and 64.7% of CHPS compounds. Distribution targets were unmet by 41.2% of districts, 22.2% of hospitals, 23.5% of health centers, and 29.4% of CHPS compounds. Information systems constituted the most critical vulnerability across primary care facilities, falling below the benchmark in 52.9% of districts, 50.0% of hospitals, 76.5% of health centers, and 88.2% of CHPS compounds. Conclusion Although the central and regional tiers demonstrated robust capacity, vaccine management remains fragile at the subdistrict and primary healthcare facility levels. Targeted interventions are urgently required to upgrade cold chain infrastructure, optimize last-mile logistics, improve stock governance, and enhance health worker capacity for data management to ensure vaccine security and efficacy in Ghana.

Research Square
University of Health and Allied Sciences (GH)
Good health and well-being, Industry, innovation and infrastructure
Vaccine Coverage and Hesitancy
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon