Recruitment in the Bariatric surgery for the Reduction of cArdioVascular Events (BRAVE) trial: lessons learned

Slow or inadequate recruitment to clinical trials, particularly those with complex interventions, can be a major threat to study completion and statistical power. Three complementary strategies were used to examine recruitment challenges in the BRAVE study, an ongoing international randomized controlled trial comparing metabolic/bariatric surgery versus guideline-directed medical weight management, where recruitment was anticipated to be difficult. These included: an adjunctive qualitative study (SWIFT), site investigator and research staff survey, and focused participant engagement sessions. The overall objectives were to (i) identify barriers to recruitment and drivers of study participation from the perspectives of both invited participants as well as research staff, and (ii) use this information to develop strategies to improve recruitment. A total of 54 unique individuals participated across the three initiatives (SWIFT, n = 24; survey, n = 25; engagement sessions, n = 5). Key drivers of participation included trust in referring clinicians, readiness for lifestyle change, family support and the integral role of research staff, while barriers included fear of weight-related stigma, concerns about autonomy arising from the randomization process, and logistical constraints. The site survey indicated benefit from greater investigator and research staff involvement (which requires higher levels of funding), implementation of multiple patient-centered strategies (e.g., tailored recruitment aids, streamlined surgical work-up), and strong, regular communication and collaboration among participants, staff, and clinicians. Our findings underscore the need for study-specific recruitment plans and evaluation of procedures while clinical trials are ongoing. Successful recruitment in complex clinical trials requires substantial investigator and staff effort and involvement, institutional coordination, and sustained patient engagement. Based on these insights, targeted strategies were undertaken to improve recruitment procedures in the ongoing BRAVE trial. Slow or inadequate recruitment to clinical trials, especially those with complex interventions may lead to study discontinuation or reduced ability to answer important research question. We used three strategies to examine recruitment challenges in the early phase of an ongoing randomized controlled trial, BRAVE, comparing metabolic/bariatric surgery versus guideline-directed medical weight management. These included a qualitative study, researcher and staff surveys, and focused participant engagement sessions. We found that successful recruitment was more likely when individuals trusted referring physicians, felt that their wellbeing was being prioritized, were psychologically ready for the lifestyle change that would accompany obesity treatment, and were consistently engaged by the study team across all phases of the recruitment process. Barriers to recruitment included fear of weight-related stigma that might accompany obesity treatment, concerns about being selected for the study group they did not prefer, and other pressures related to being in the study (e.g., loss of time or income). Surveys of study personnel showed that recruitment worked best when study clinicians and research staff were closely involved, when teams used several patient-friendly approaches (e.g., personalized information, less burdensome pre-surgery procedures), and when there was strong communication among patients, research staff, and clinicians. Overall, through our three initiatives, we found that study-specific recruitment plans and timely review of those plans is necessary. Successful recruitment into complex trials requires substantial investigator and study staff effort, institutional coordination, and sustained participant engagement.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Trials
Published
2026-11-16
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1186/s13063-026-10081-2
Primary Topic
Ethics in Clinical Research
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00

Funders

Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Recruitment in the Bariatric surgery for the Reduction of cArdioVascular Events (BRAVE) trial: lessons learned

Roselyne Villiard, Rémi Kouz, Satya Dash, Susan Michelle Jack et al.
3 links
Trials
Ethics in Clinical Research
article

Recruitment in the Bariatric surgery for the Reduction of cArdioVascular Events (BRAVE) trial: lessons learned

Roselyne Villiard, Rémi Kouz, Satya Dash, Susan Michelle Jack, Michael Hugh McGillion, Jorge A. Wong, Mateo Iwanowski, Amin Andalib, Emma Alaine van Reekum, Myriam Pettigrew, Elorm Vowotor, Dênis Pajecki, Ryan Davey, Krista Hardy, Hassan Mir, Dawn Agapay, S Rangarajan, Jessica Tyrwhitt, Salim Yusuf, William Howe, Paul Poirier, Ori Rotstein, Tracy Harrington-Vrkljan, Mehran Anvari, Jessica Weatherby, Shrikant. I. Bangdiwala, Nathalia Lys Trindade Santos, Christine Odicho
article en

Abstract

Slow or inadequate recruitment to clinical trials, particularly those with complex interventions, can be a major threat to study completion and statistical power. Three complementary strategies were used to examine recruitment challenges in the BRAVE study, an ongoing international randomized controlled trial comparing metabolic/bariatric surgery versus guideline-directed medical weight management, where recruitment was anticipated to be difficult. These included: an adjunctive qualitative study (SWIFT), site investigator and research staff survey, and focused participant engagement sessions. The overall objectives were to (i) identify barriers to recruitment and drivers of study participation from the perspectives of both invited participants as well as research staff, and (ii) use this information to develop strategies to improve recruitment. A total of 54 unique individuals participated across the three initiatives (SWIFT, n = 24; survey, n = 25; engagement sessions, n = 5). Key drivers of participation included trust in referring clinicians, readiness for lifestyle change, family support and the integral role of research staff, while barriers included fear of weight-related stigma, concerns about autonomy arising from the randomization process, and logistical constraints. The site survey indicated benefit from greater investigator and research staff involvement (which requires higher levels of funding), implementation of multiple patient-centered strategies (e.g., tailored recruitment aids, streamlined surgical work-up), and strong, regular communication and collaboration among participants, staff, and clinicians. Our findings underscore the need for study-specific recruitment plans and evaluation of procedures while clinical trials are ongoing. Successful recruitment in complex clinical trials requires substantial investigator and staff effort and involvement, institutional coordination, and sustained patient engagement. Based on these insights, targeted strategies were undertaken to improve recruitment procedures in the ongoing BRAVE trial. Slow or inadequate recruitment to clinical trials, especially those with complex interventions may lead to study discontinuation or reduced ability to answer important research question. We used three strategies to examine recruitment challenges in the early phase of an ongoing randomized controlled trial, BRAVE, comparing metabolic/bariatric surgery versus guideline-directed medical weight management. These included a qualitative study, researcher and staff surveys, and focused participant engagement sessions. We found that successful recruitment was more likely when individuals trusted referring physicians, felt that their wellbeing was being prioritized, were psychologically ready for the lifestyle change that would accompany obesity treatment, and were consistently engaged by the study team across all phases of the recruitment process. Barriers to recruitment included fear of weight-related stigma that might accompany obesity treatment, concerns about being selected for the study group they did not prefer, and other pressures related to being in the study (e.g., loss of time or income). Surveys of study personnel showed that recruitment worked best when study clinicians and research staff were closely involved, when teams used several patient-friendly approaches (e.g., personalized information, less burdensome pre-surgery procedures), and when there was strong communication among patients, research staff, and clinicians. Overall, through our three initiatives, we found that study-specific recruitment plans and timely review of those plans is necessary. Successful recruitment into complex trials requires substantial investigator and study staff effort, institutional coordination, and sustained participant engagement.

Trials
Western University (CA), St. Michael's Hospital (CA), University of Ottawa (CA), University of Toronto (CA), Population Health Research Institute (CA), Hospital Alemão Oswaldo Cruz (BR), St Michael's Hospital (GB), Hospital Del Mar (ES), Institut universitaire de cardiologie et de pneumologie de Québec (CA), Hôpital du Sacré-Cœur de Montréal (CA), Hospital del Mar Research Institute (ES), Université Laval (CA), Toronto General Hospital Research Institute (CA), Unity Health Toronto (CA), Ottawa Heart Institute (CA), Keenan Research Centre for Biomedical Science (CA), University of Manitoba (CA), McGill University (CA), St. Joseph’s Healthcare Hamilton (CA), Université de Montréal (CA), Hamilton Health Sciences (CA), McMaster University (CA)
Physicians' Services Incorporated Foundation, Canadian Institutes of Health Research, Institute of Population and Public Health
Good health and well-being
Ethics in Clinical Research
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon