Free Meals, Foreclosed Markets: An Input-Process-Output-Outcome Analysis of Indonesia's Free Nutritious Meals Program in Urban and Peri-Urban Jakarta and Bekasi

Indonesia’s Free Nutritious Meals Program (Makan Bergizi Gratis, MBG) presents a striking policy paradox: a fiscal commitment of unprecedented scale, IDR 335 trillion in 2026, of which 83.4% is reallocated from the education budget, deployed against a backdrop of falling but still WHO-threshold-exceeding child stunting (19.8 percent in 2024), has been accompanied by mounting evidence of implementation failure rather than the promised revitalization of local food economies. Understanding this paradox requires moving beyond input-level metrics of budget absorption and caloric coverage toward a staged evaluation of implementation, and why it diverges systematically between core-urban and peri-urban settings. We apply an Input-Process- Output-Outcome (IPOO) evaluation framework, integrated with Urban Bias Theory (Lipton, 1977) as an explanatory account of spatial disparity, and benchmarked against the home-grown school feeding model documented globally by the World Food Programme. Drawing on verbatim field interviews conducted in July 2026 at four sites, two in core-urban Jakarta and two in peri-urban Bekasi Regency, the study triangulates qualitative findings against a national household survey of 1,721 to 1,868 respondents conducted by the Center of Economic and Law Studies (CELIOS) and official government budget and food-safety incident data. Findings show that fiscal asymmetry at the input stage forces schools to cut extracurricular budgets and starves kitchen operators of working capital; logistical and food-safety failures at the process stage expose peri-urban kitchens to biologically hazardous production schedules consistent with the country’s highest provincial poisoning caseload; standardized menus at the output stage generate significant food waste and rely disproportionately on ultra-processed food; and at the outcome stage the program measurably displaces, rather than integrates, school canteens and neighborhood micro-enterprises, with national simulations projecting job losses of up to 1.94 million workers in the food micro-enterprise sector. The novelty of this study lies in demonstrating, through paired urban-peri-urban fieldwork triangulated with national secondary data, that Indonesia’s centralized meal-procurement architecture systematically reproduces rather than corrects urban bias, in contrast to the locally rooted procurement model that international evidence identifies as more distributionally favorable. Policy recommendations addressing disbursement timing, food-safety governance, and local-economy integration are discussed.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
KnE Social Sciences
Published
2026-11-16
DOI
https://doi.org/10.18502/kss.v11i9.22028
Primary Topic
Public Administration in Developing Nations
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Free Meals, Foreclosed Markets: An Input-Process-Output-Outcome Analysis of Indonesia's Free Nutritious Meals Program in Urban and Peri-Urban Jakarta and Bekasi

Retnayu Prasetyanti, Daffa Chairi Salsabil, Said Tonthowi, Elang Bani Ibrahim Panjiwinata
KnE Social Sciences
Public Administration in Developing Nations
article

Free Meals, Foreclosed Markets: An Input-Process-Output-Outcome Analysis of Indonesia's Free Nutritious Meals Program in Urban and Peri-Urban Jakarta and Bekasi

Retnayu Prasetyanti, Daffa Chairi Salsabil, Said Tonthowi, Elang Bani Ibrahim Panjiwinata
article en

Abstract

Indonesia’s Free Nutritious Meals Program (Makan Bergizi Gratis, MBG) presents a striking policy paradox: a fiscal commitment of unprecedented scale, IDR 335 trillion in 2026, of which 83.4% is reallocated from the education budget, deployed against a backdrop of falling but still WHO-threshold-exceeding child stunting (19.8 percent in 2024), has been accompanied by mounting evidence of implementation failure rather than the promised revitalization of local food economies. Understanding this paradox requires moving beyond input-level metrics of budget absorption and caloric coverage toward a staged evaluation of implementation, and why it diverges systematically between core-urban and peri-urban settings. We apply an Input-Process- Output-Outcome (IPOO) evaluation framework, integrated with Urban Bias Theory (Lipton, 1977) as an explanatory account of spatial disparity, and benchmarked against the home-grown school feeding model documented globally by the World Food Programme. Drawing on verbatim field interviews conducted in July 2026 at four sites, two in core-urban Jakarta and two in peri-urban Bekasi Regency, the study triangulates qualitative findings against a national household survey of 1,721 to 1,868 respondents conducted by the Center of Economic and Law Studies (CELIOS) and official government budget and food-safety incident data. Findings show that fiscal asymmetry at the input stage forces schools to cut extracurricular budgets and starves kitchen operators of working capital; logistical and food-safety failures at the process stage expose peri-urban kitchens to biologically hazardous production schedules consistent with the country’s highest provincial poisoning caseload; standardized menus at the output stage generate significant food waste and rely disproportionately on ultra-processed food; and at the outcome stage the program measurably displaces, rather than integrates, school canteens and neighborhood micro-enterprises, with national simulations projecting job losses of up to 1.94 million workers in the food micro-enterprise sector. The novelty of this study lies in demonstrating, through paired urban-peri-urban fieldwork triangulated with national secondary data, that Indonesia’s centralized meal-procurement architecture systematically reproduces rather than corrects urban bias, in contrast to the locally rooted procurement model that international evidence identifies as more distributionally favorable. Policy recommendations addressing disbursement timing, food-safety governance, and local-economy integration are discussed.

KnE Social SciencesVol. 11(9)
Politeknik STIA LAN Jakarta (ID)
No poverty, Zero hunger, Reduced inequalities, Sustainable cities and communities
Public Administration in Developing Nations
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon