Securing the Semantic Supply Chain: Meaning as a Foundation of Trust Infrastructure

Verifiable credentials are becoming legal and economic infrastructure. With a trusted binding between the signing key and the issuer, a signature authenticates the signed content; it does not by itself fix what that content means to the party that reads it. Meaning reaches a verifier through a supply chain of its own: JSON-LD contexts, vocabularies, ontologies, validation shapes, crosswalks, rulebooks, Type Metadata and codec tables. Each can be substituted, rolled back, frozen, shown differently to different verifiers, or withdrawn without verifiers noticing. W3C Data Integrity already requires approved contexts, or equivalent protections, at each verifier. We show what this leaves open and propose mechanisms to close it. In laboratory tests with an open harness on production libraries, changing mutable, decision-relevant context bytes that the verifier did not authenticate independently changed a credential's meaning without invalidating signatures over its JSON text (JCS) or over an envelope. On one CBOR-LD library, a synthetic compact label became unreadable after a routine vocabulary update and, under a profile that signs the compressed bytes, decoded to a different meaning with a valid signature. Unauthenticated input imposed seconds of computation before the signature check when canonicalisation had no work limit; the tested canonicalisation library's default limit stops such input but rejects some legitimate credentials. A formal model of the semantic supply chain states the core results with proof sketches and model-checks the stateful mechanisms in 66 cases on small instances. From these results we derive 30 mechanisms, among them release engineering for meaning, lexical-first proofs that commit to the semantic graph, codec binding for long-lived carriers, receipts that record the meaning a decision applied, attested decision engines whose receipts the proposed profile requires to be attributable to an accountable legal person, and a profile for compliance evidence. We propose 91 requirements as a baseline for a high-assurance profile of W3C VCDM 2.0; no W3C group has adopted them. The problem is not specific to W3C VCDM: SD-JWT VC and ISO mdoc take their meaning from rulebooks and Type Metadata, and we give a first mapping, by design reasoning, of which mechanisms would transfer; none is specified or tested for those formats. The results bind meaning, not its truth; hardware isolation is simulated, not demonstrated, and enrolment for attribution is specified, not implemented. Canonical HTML edition: https://spherity.github.io/spherity-research/securing-semantic-supply-chain.html

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-16
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24293612
Primary Topic
Semantic Web and Ontologies
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Securing the Semantic Supply Chain: Meaning as a Foundation of Trust Infrastructure

Carsten Stöcker
4 links
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Semantic Web and Ontologies
article

Securing the Semantic Supply Chain: Meaning as a Foundation of Trust Infrastructure

Carsten Stöcker
article en

Abstract

Verifiable credentials are becoming legal and economic infrastructure. With a trusted binding between the signing key and the issuer, a signature authenticates the signed content; it does not by itself fix what that content means to the party that reads it. Meaning reaches a verifier through a supply chain of its own: JSON-LD contexts, vocabularies, ontologies, validation shapes, crosswalks, rulebooks, Type Metadata and codec tables. Each can be substituted, rolled back, frozen, shown differently to different verifiers, or withdrawn without verifiers noticing. W3C Data Integrity already requires approved contexts, or equivalent protections, at each verifier. We show what this leaves open and propose mechanisms to close it. In laboratory tests with an open harness on production libraries, changing mutable, decision-relevant context bytes that the verifier did not authenticate independently changed a credential's meaning without invalidating signatures over its JSON text (JCS) or over an envelope. On one CBOR-LD library, a synthetic compact label became unreadable after a routine vocabulary update and, under a profile that signs the compressed bytes, decoded to a different meaning with a valid signature. Unauthenticated input imposed seconds of computation before the signature check when canonicalisation had no work limit; the tested canonicalisation library's default limit stops such input but rejects some legitimate credentials. A formal model of the semantic supply chain states the core results with proof sketches and model-checks the stateful mechanisms in 66 cases on small instances. From these results we derive 30 mechanisms, among them release engineering for meaning, lexical-first proofs that commit to the semantic graph, codec binding for long-lived carriers, receipts that record the meaning a decision applied, attested decision engines whose receipts the proposed profile requires to be attributable to an accountable legal person, and a profile for compliance evidence. We propose 91 requirements as a baseline for a high-assurance profile of W3C VCDM 2.0; no W3C group has adopted them. The problem is not specific to W3C VCDM: SD-JWT VC and ISO mdoc take their meaning from rulebooks and Type Metadata, and we give a first mapping, by design reasoning, of which mechanisms would transfer; none is specified or tested for those formats. The results bind meaning, not its truth; hardware isolation is simulated, not demonstrated, and enrolment for attribution is specified, not implemented. Canonical HTML edition: https://spherity.github.io/spherity-research/securing-semantic-supply-chain.html

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Semantic Web and Ontologies
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon