Consent for intensive care research involving adults who lack decision-making capacity: A jurisdictional analysis of Australia's fragmented framework

Critically ill adults frequently cannot consent to research because of sedation, delirium, shock or mechanical ventilation, yet safe intensive care depends on evidence generated in this population; several treatments once regarded as standard care proved harmful when finally tested in randomised trials. The ethical framework for enrolling adults who lack decision-making capacity is national—the National Health and Medical Research Council National Statement on Ethical Conduct in Human Research (2025), in effect since 23 June 2026—but legal authority for substitute consent is conferred by eight state and territory statutes that differ in terminology, in decision-maker hierarchies, in whether they address research at all, and whether they permit enrolment in an emergency. Mapping four representative study archetypes across all eight jurisdictions shows that the lawful basis for enrolling the same patient shifts with study design as much as with geography; differing statutory definitions, tribunal involvement and the transition to the 2025 National Statement produce material and avoidable inconsistency. Contemporary Australian intensive care trials show that practice has converged on the National Statement while the underlying legislation has not; the resulting inconsistency risks inequity, underrepresentation of critically ill patients, and bias in the evidence generated. We set out principles for reform (Box 1): nationally consistent framing of substitute consent for research—common terminology and legal principles, an explicit emergency-research pathway in every jurisdiction, and consistent interpretation within each jurisdiction—developed with consumers and with the clinicians and clinical research nurses who obtain consent, and taken forward with formal endorsement from the relevant professional bodies.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Critical Care and Resuscitation
Published
2026-11-16
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ccrj.2026.100230
Primary Topic
Ethics in Clinical Research
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Consent for intensive care research involving adults who lack decision-making capacity: A jurisdictional analysis of Australia's fragmented framework

Steven Galluccio, Sumeet Rai, Andrew Alexander Udy, Heidi Buhr et al.
Critical Care and Resuscitation
Ethics in Clinical Research
article

Consent for intensive care research involving adults who lack decision-making capacity: A jurisdictional analysis of Australia's fragmented framework

Steven Galluccio, Sumeet Rai, Andrew Alexander Udy, Heidi Buhr, Samantha Bates, Richard E. McAllister, Joanne McIntyre, Ary Serpa Neto, Shailesh Bihari, Manoj Krishan Saxena, Adam M. Deane, Mark Philip Plummer, Lewis T. Campbell, Balasubramanian Venkatesh, Priya Nair, Steven A. R. Webb
article en

Abstract

Critically ill adults frequently cannot consent to research because of sedation, delirium, shock or mechanical ventilation, yet safe intensive care depends on evidence generated in this population; several treatments once regarded as standard care proved harmful when finally tested in randomised trials. The ethical framework for enrolling adults who lack decision-making capacity is national—the National Health and Medical Research Council National Statement on Ethical Conduct in Human Research (2025), in effect since 23 June 2026—but legal authority for substitute consent is conferred by eight state and territory statutes that differ in terminology, in decision-maker hierarchies, in whether they address research at all, and whether they permit enrolment in an emergency. Mapping four representative study archetypes across all eight jurisdictions shows that the lawful basis for enrolling the same patient shifts with study design as much as with geography; differing statutory definitions, tribunal involvement and the transition to the 2025 National Statement produce material and avoidable inconsistency. Contemporary Australian intensive care trials show that practice has converged on the National Statement while the underlying legislation has not; the resulting inconsistency risks inequity, underrepresentation of critically ill patients, and bias in the evidence generated. We set out principles for reform (Box 1): nationally consistent framing of substitute consent for research—common terminology and legal principles, an explicit emergency-research pathway in every jurisdiction, and consistent interpretation within each jurisdiction—developed with consumers and with the clinicians and clinical research nurses who obtain consent, and taken forward with formal endorsement from the relevant professional bodies.

Critical Care and ResuscitationVol. 29(1)
Australian National University (AU), St John of God Subiaco Hospital (AU), Royal Adelaide Hospital (AU), The Royal Melbourne Hospital (AU), The University of Melbourne (AU), Flinders University (AU), Royal Prince Alfred Hospital (AU), Hospital Israelita Albert Einstein (BR), Austin Hospital (AU), Princess Alexandra Hospital (AU), The Alfred Hospital (AU), Flinders Medical Centre (AU), Royal Hobart Hospital (AU), UNSW Sydney (AU), St Vincent's Hospital Sydney (AU), The George Institute for Global Health (AU), Western Health (AU), St George Hospital (AU), Royal Darwin Hospital (AU), ACT Government (AU), Caring Futures Institute (AU), Monash University (AU)
Good health and well-being, Peace, justice, and strong institutions
Ethics in Clinical Research
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon