Which Rank-Dependent Inequality Indices Decompose? The S-Gini Family and the Heikkuri-Schief Axioms
Heikkuri and Schief (2026) give axioms for splitting an inequality index into within-group and between-group terms, showing that the Gini coefficient has a unique decomposition satisfying them. We apply the same axioms to every rank-dependent (Mehran-Yaari) inequality index with a strictly concave weighting function and finite right derivative at zero. We prove that the extended (S-) Gini indices each admit a unique decomposition, provide its explicit within group power mean formula, and establish a complete dichotomy between uniqueness and a continuum of decompositions across the class showing in particular that the Bonferroni index admits a continuum, while log-periodic perturbations of the Gini yield non, S-Gini indices with a unique decomposition. We also show that no index in this class can be computed from subgroup indices, sizes, and any finite set of subgroup moments, so all results hold under Heikkuri and Schief's strengthened normalization axiom.
Authors
- Saurabh Godara
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-16
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24281556
- Primary Topic
- Income, Poverty, and Inequality
- Type
- preprint