Loop Mass Balance for a Single-Material Recovery Loop: A Lean Proof

Working paper, not peer reviewed. Nothing in this record is field-validated. Scope and novelty. Project P3 states and proves the formal core of a circular-economy kernel for Viridis OS: loop mass balance, cascaded recovery, a recovery-adjusted work floor and an N-partner symbiosis condition. These are elementary accounting and inequality results about the stated models, not new theorems. The N-partner condition generalises the two-partner Reciprocity Corridor (doi:10.5281/zenodo.21971047), and the work floor extends the Useful and Dissipated Work Ledger (doi:10.5281/zenodo.22736716). We have not searched the literature exhaustively and claim no novelty. Each result holds only inside its stated model. It says nothing about any measured recovery rate, retention, cost, value or material, about whether deployed kernel code implements the rule faithfully, or about any environmental outcome. The work floor is a bound on modelled efficiency; it is not a Landauer bound and does not rely on the Intelligence Bound, which remains a conjecture. We study the simplest dynamic model of a circular material loop. A constant demand D >= 0 is met partly by recovered material, a share r in [0,1], and partly by virgin input V = D(1-r). A secondary stock evolves as S(t+1) = rho S(t) + rD with retention rho in [0,1). We give a Lean 4 proof, against Mathlib, of the sealed statement P3.LoopMassBalance. The statement has five parts. The virgin input satisfies 0 <= V <= D. The stock gap obeys the exact closed form S(t) - S* = rho^t (S(0) - S*) with fixed point S* = rD/(1-rho). The stock converges to S* from any initial value. Cumulative virgin input over T periods equals T D (1-r). For D > 0 and T > 0, cumulative virgin input is strictly decreasing in r on [0,1]. The proof is about fifty lines long and uses only standard Mathlib lemmas. These results are accounting identities of the model. They say nothing about any measured recovery rate, retention rate, demand or material. Verification. a Lean 4 proof of P3.LoopMassBalance, a statement fixed before the proof attempt, machine-checked against Mathlib and replayed through the Lean kernel using only the standard axioms Run record, certification page and reproducible package: https://github.com/jdhart81/viridis-research/tree/main/runs/2026-11-15_P3 AI use: this version was drafted by an AI research agent (Claude, by Anthropic) running the Viridis research engine. Formal claims are checked by the Lean 4 kernel, empirical claims by re-running their analysis in a sandbox, and all are labelled by an automated verifier. The agent may call the Aristotle prover (Harmonic) for help with proof search; a proof counts only if the Lean kernel accepts it. Justin D. Hart directs the research and is the accountable author. No AI system is listed as an author or contributor, which Zenodo does not allow.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-16
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24281826
Primary Topic
Sustainable Supply Chain Management
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

Loop Mass Balance for a Single-Material Recovery Loop: A Lean Proof

Justin Hart
1 links
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Sustainable Supply Chain Management
preprint

Loop Mass Balance for a Single-Material Recovery Loop: A Lean Proof

Justin Hart
preprint en

Abstract

Working paper, not peer reviewed. Nothing in this record is field-validated. Scope and novelty. Project P3 states and proves the formal core of a circular-economy kernel for Viridis OS: loop mass balance, cascaded recovery, a recovery-adjusted work floor and an N-partner symbiosis condition. These are elementary accounting and inequality results about the stated models, not new theorems. The N-partner condition generalises the two-partner Reciprocity Corridor (doi:10.5281/zenodo.21971047), and the work floor extends the Useful and Dissipated Work Ledger (doi:10.5281/zenodo.22736716). We have not searched the literature exhaustively and claim no novelty. Each result holds only inside its stated model. It says nothing about any measured recovery rate, retention, cost, value or material, about whether deployed kernel code implements the rule faithfully, or about any environmental outcome. The work floor is a bound on modelled efficiency; it is not a Landauer bound and does not rely on the Intelligence Bound, which remains a conjecture. We study the simplest dynamic model of a circular material loop. A constant demand D >= 0 is met partly by recovered material, a share r in [0,1], and partly by virgin input V = D(1-r). A secondary stock evolves as S(t+1) = rho S(t) + rD with retention rho in [0,1). We give a Lean 4 proof, against Mathlib, of the sealed statement P3.LoopMassBalance. The statement has five parts. The virgin input satisfies 0 <= V <= D. The stock gap obeys the exact closed form S(t) - S* = rho^t (S(0) - S*) with fixed point S* = rD/(1-rho). The stock converges to S* from any initial value. Cumulative virgin input over T periods equals T D (1-r). For D > 0 and T > 0, cumulative virgin input is strictly decreasing in r on [0,1]. The proof is about fifty lines long and uses only standard Mathlib lemmas. These results are accounting identities of the model. They say nothing about any measured recovery rate, retention rate, demand or material. Verification. a Lean 4 proof of P3.LoopMassBalance, a statement fixed before the proof attempt, machine-checked against Mathlib and replayed through the Lean kernel using only the standard axioms Run record, certification page and reproducible package: https://github.com/jdhart81/viridis-research/tree/main/runs/2026-11-15_P3 AI use: this version was drafted by an AI research agent (Claude, by Anthropic) running the Viridis research engine. Formal claims are checked by the Lean 4 kernel, empirical claims by re-running their analysis in a sandbox, and all are labelled by an automated verifier. The agent may call the Aristotle prover (Harmonic) for help with proof search; a proof counts only if the Lean kernel accepts it. Justin D. Hart directs the research and is the accountable author. No AI system is listed as an author or contributor, which Zenodo does not allow.

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Responsible consumption and production
Sustainable Supply Chain Management
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon