Comfort, stretch, panic: Managing affect to support creative learning in complex problem-solving

Universities are increasingly encouraged to engage students with complex real-world problems, such as those characterised by the UN’s Sustainable Development Goals (Schmitz et al., 2026). Doing so leverages their emerging disciplinary knowledge and requires the development of broader competencies that are relevant to industry and other non-academic contexts (Brundiers et al., 2021). However, confronting real-world problems can be a more intimidating and emotionally charged learning process than disciplinarily bounded or pre-prepared case study work. These problems lack clear boundaries, have rich but always-incomplete information available to characterise them, are dynamic, and students may feel directly entangled with them via their everyday lives (Veltman et al., 2021; Wickson et al., 2025). Addressing complex problems requires inner transformation by educators and students to align their emerging skills and externally oriented knowledge development (Ives et al., 2023; Stein, 2021). When engaging in real-world-problem inquiry, digital tools including web search, databases and GenAI make massive quantities of information available. However, quantity is not necessarily paired with credibility, quality, and contextual relevance, and this amplification and ease of access may paradoxically increase student uncertainty and undermine creative confidence (Jose et al., 2025). This digitally-broadened information landscape, when combined with the inherent complexity of real-world problems, can trigger feelings of anxiety, disengagement or lower motivation, placing strain on classroom relationships, such as educator–student and team connections, and requiring strategic educator management. This poster will share preliminary results from a practice-led doctoral study framed by the research question: How can an educator creatively manage affect in a learning environment to support students’ creative development? The research draws data from two iterations of a 60-student interdisciplinary master’s unit at a large Australian university. In the unit, students work to create innovative projects to address local real-world systemic problems, with significant openness in the boundaries of the brief and range of solution options framed as viable. The presentation will share highlights of a reflexive thematic analysis of students’ short, written reflections on affective experience during the solution prototyping and final proposal stages of the creative process. Students experienced strong but mixed emotions, which temporally varied at an individual level and were often held simultaneously. For example, during prototyping, students commonly reported experiencing feelings such as frustration or uncertainty, and at the same time, pride or confidence – that is, positive and negative affect coexisted within individual students, and the cohort, simultaneously. These complex affective dynamics required careful educator management to encourage student progress. The poster will then feature an emerging typology, with examples, of human-centred teaching strategies deployed to support and enable students to work with and reflect on their emotional responses while seeking to creatively express ideas. These strategies ranged from whole-of-class, to small-group, to peer-to-peer, and student-to-GenAI approaches. Educator-researcher evaluations of the efficacy of these strategies will be offered, along with provocations to drive further dialogue on this topic.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
ASCILITE Publications
Published
2026-11-17
DOI
https://doi.org/10.65106/apubs.2026.3423
Primary Topic
Problem and Project Based Learning
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Comfort, stretch, panic: Managing affect to support creative learning in complex problem-solving

Joannette J. Bos, Ilya Fridman, Lisa Grocott, Yuan Li
ASCILITE Publications
Problem and Project Based Learning
article

Comfort, stretch, panic: Managing affect to support creative learning in complex problem-solving

Joannette J. Bos, Ilya Fridman, Lisa Grocott, Yuan Li
article en

Abstract

Universities are increasingly encouraged to engage students with complex real-world problems, such as those characterised by the UN’s Sustainable Development Goals (Schmitz et al., 2026). Doing so leverages their emerging disciplinary knowledge and requires the development of broader competencies that are relevant to industry and other non-academic contexts (Brundiers et al., 2021). However, confronting real-world problems can be a more intimidating and emotionally charged learning process than disciplinarily bounded or pre-prepared case study work. These problems lack clear boundaries, have rich but always-incomplete information available to characterise them, are dynamic, and students may feel directly entangled with them via their everyday lives (Veltman et al., 2021; Wickson et al., 2025). Addressing complex problems requires inner transformation by educators and students to align their emerging skills and externally oriented knowledge development (Ives et al., 2023; Stein, 2021). When engaging in real-world-problem inquiry, digital tools including web search, databases and GenAI make massive quantities of information available. However, quantity is not necessarily paired with credibility, quality, and contextual relevance, and this amplification and ease of access may paradoxically increase student uncertainty and undermine creative confidence (Jose et al., 2025). This digitally-broadened information landscape, when combined with the inherent complexity of real-world problems, can trigger feelings of anxiety, disengagement or lower motivation, placing strain on classroom relationships, such as educator–student and team connections, and requiring strategic educator management. This poster will share preliminary results from a practice-led doctoral study framed by the research question: How can an educator creatively manage affect in a learning environment to support students’ creative development? The research draws data from two iterations of a 60-student interdisciplinary master’s unit at a large Australian university. In the unit, students work to create innovative projects to address local real-world systemic problems, with significant openness in the boundaries of the brief and range of solution options framed as viable. The presentation will share highlights of a reflexive thematic analysis of students’ short, written reflections on affective experience during the solution prototyping and final proposal stages of the creative process. Students experienced strong but mixed emotions, which temporally varied at an individual level and were often held simultaneously. For example, during prototyping, students commonly reported experiencing feelings such as frustration or uncertainty, and at the same time, pride or confidence – that is, positive and negative affect coexisted within individual students, and the cohort, simultaneously. These complex affective dynamics required careful educator management to encourage student progress. The poster will then feature an emerging typology, with examples, of human-centred teaching strategies deployed to support and enable students to work with and reflect on their emotional responses while seeking to creatively express ideas. These strategies ranged from whole-of-class, to small-group, to peer-to-peer, and student-to-GenAI approaches. Educator-researcher evaluations of the efficacy of these strategies will be offered, along with provocations to drive further dialogue on this topic.

ASCILITE Publications
Monash University (AU)
Quality education
Problem and Project Based Learning
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon