ChatGPT concordance with guidelines and tumour board treatment recommendations in gastrointestinal cancer

Abstract Purpose Large language models may support guideline screening and multidisciplinary tumour board preparation in gastrointestinal oncology, but their performance in postoperative treatment assessment remains insufficiently characterized. To evaluate guideline concordance, tumour board concordance, reproducibility, and discordance patterns of ChatGPT-generated postoperative treatment recommendations in gastrointestinal cancer. Methods Single-centre exploratory cross-sectional study using retrospectively assembled clinical case vignettes assessed by a large language model (ChatGPT). Thirty adult patients with histologically confirmed pancreatic, gastric, or colorectal adenocarcinoma who underwent curative-intent surgery and subsequent multidisciplinary tumour board (MTB) review at a German tertiary referral centre (January 2025–January 2026) were included. Structured vignettes were entered into ChatGPT via a standardised prompt within a controlled guideline environment; each case underwent three independent runs (run-level) with majority voting to derive the decisive treatment recommendation (case-level). The primary outcome was concordance of ChatGPT recommendations with German guideline-based postoperative treatment recommendations on the case-level. Secondary outcomes included concordance with MTB recommendations, reproducibility, cross-guideline comparison, and qualitative characterisation of discordant recommendations (divided in minor or major deviation). Results ChatGPT-generated majority-vote recommendations were fully concordant with German guideline-based recommendations in 21 of 30 cases (70%). Concordance was higher in pancreatic and gastric cancer (8 of 10 cases [80%] each) than in colorectal cancer (5 of 10 cases [50%]). Multidisciplinary tumour board recommendations demonstrated the same overall concordance rate (21 of 30 cases [70%]). Concordance decreased in clinically advanced disease stages. Cross-classification demonstrated complete guideline concordance in both ChatGPT-generated and tumour board recommendations in 17 of 30 cases (56.7%), whereas major LLM discordance despite guideline-adherent tumour board recommendations was uncommon (1 of 30 cases [3.3%]). In exploratory run-level analysis, 23 of 90 outputs (25.6%) were discordant, comprising 14 (15.6%) major and 9 (10.0%) minor deviations. Complete agreement across repeated runs occurred in 61 of 90 case-guideline combinations (67.8%). Conclusion ChatGPT-generated treatment recommendations showed relevant but variable concordance with guideline-based and multidisciplinary tumour board recommendations. Discordance clustered in clinically complex treatment situations, supporting a possible role for LLM-based systems in guideline screening and tumour board preparation while requiring expert physician oversight. Trial registration ClinicalTrals.gov: #NCT07592338.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Langenbeck s Archives of Surgery
Published
2026-11-16
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/s00423-026-04351-5
Primary Topic
Artificial Intelligence in Healthcare and Education
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

ChatGPT concordance with guidelines and tumour board treatment recommendations in gastrointestinal cancer

Sebastian Lünse, Richard Hunger, René Mantke, Niklas Krollmann et al.
Langenbeck s Archives of Surgery
Artificial Intelligence in Healthcare and Education
article

ChatGPT concordance with guidelines and tumour board treatment recommendations in gastrointestinal cancer

Sebastian Lünse, Richard Hunger, René Mantke, Niklas Krollmann, Annika Mall
article en

Abstract

Abstract Purpose Large language models may support guideline screening and multidisciplinary tumour board preparation in gastrointestinal oncology, but their performance in postoperative treatment assessment remains insufficiently characterized. To evaluate guideline concordance, tumour board concordance, reproducibility, and discordance patterns of ChatGPT-generated postoperative treatment recommendations in gastrointestinal cancer. Methods Single-centre exploratory cross-sectional study using retrospectively assembled clinical case vignettes assessed by a large language model (ChatGPT). Thirty adult patients with histologically confirmed pancreatic, gastric, or colorectal adenocarcinoma who underwent curative-intent surgery and subsequent multidisciplinary tumour board (MTB) review at a German tertiary referral centre (January 2025–January 2026) were included. Structured vignettes were entered into ChatGPT via a standardised prompt within a controlled guideline environment; each case underwent three independent runs (run-level) with majority voting to derive the decisive treatment recommendation (case-level). The primary outcome was concordance of ChatGPT recommendations with German guideline-based postoperative treatment recommendations on the case-level. Secondary outcomes included concordance with MTB recommendations, reproducibility, cross-guideline comparison, and qualitative characterisation of discordant recommendations (divided in minor or major deviation). Results ChatGPT-generated majority-vote recommendations were fully concordant with German guideline-based recommendations in 21 of 30 cases (70%). Concordance was higher in pancreatic and gastric cancer (8 of 10 cases [80%] each) than in colorectal cancer (5 of 10 cases [50%]). Multidisciplinary tumour board recommendations demonstrated the same overall concordance rate (21 of 30 cases [70%]). Concordance decreased in clinically advanced disease stages. Cross-classification demonstrated complete guideline concordance in both ChatGPT-generated and tumour board recommendations in 17 of 30 cases (56.7%), whereas major LLM discordance despite guideline-adherent tumour board recommendations was uncommon (1 of 30 cases [3.3%]). In exploratory run-level analysis, 23 of 90 outputs (25.6%) were discordant, comprising 14 (15.6%) major and 9 (10.0%) minor deviations. Complete agreement across repeated runs occurred in 61 of 90 case-guideline combinations (67.8%). Conclusion ChatGPT-generated treatment recommendations showed relevant but variable concordance with guideline-based and multidisciplinary tumour board recommendations. Discordance clustered in clinically complex treatment situations, supporting a possible role for LLM-based systems in guideline screening and tumour board preparation while requiring expert physician oversight. Trial registration ClinicalTrals.gov: #NCT07592338.

Langenbeck s Archives of Surgery
Artificial Intelligence in Healthcare and Education
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon