Predictive Virtual Thermodynamics of Subjective Meaning: Foundational Principles
Modern physics has achieved remarkable success in describing objective physical phenomena, yet it lacks a general framework for treating subjective meaning itself as a law-governed state. We address this foundational gap by asking what structural conditions make such a domain thermodynamically representable.We show that a thermodynamic treatment of subjective meaning requires a medium supporting both an independent equilibrium state space and a meaning-dependent thermodynamic potential. We introduce this medium as a virtual thermodynamic fluid and formulate four principles defining Predictive Virtual Thermodynamics (PVT). F1 and F4 provide the necessary structural conditions, whereas F2 and F3 specify the statistical and entropic realization adopted in PVT. Without F1, subjective meaning lacks thermodynamic statehood; without F4, meaning-only transitions at fixed virtual temperature lose any nontrivial meaning-dependent free-energy difference and work bound.PVT establishes first- and second-law relations using semantic energy transfer and semantic work. A directional asymmetry excludes work-extracting reverse operations and, together with the information-thermodynamic work inequality, constrains admissible semantic transformations. For semantic order formation, the framework yields a quantitative lower bound on the required semantic work, while information-assisted feedback control shows how acquired information can reduce this requirement. Physical and mental free energies are defined on non-reducibly distinct state spaces and can be constrained by information from the same external event without direct energy exchange. PVT thereby turns the scientific treatment of subjective meaning into a concrete problem of thermodynamic statehood, distinguishability, and lawful transformation, providing a foundation for subsequent operationalization and empirical testing.
Authors
- Ken Watanuki (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0001-4632-7901)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-15
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24241646
- Primary Topic
- Advanced Thermodynamics and Statistical Mechanics
- Type
- preprint