When will it ever be enough? Black mothers and community advocates perspectives on why evidence of racism in English maternity care does not lead to action: a co-produced focus group study

Background: Racism shapes the maternity care and outcomes of Black, African, Caribbean and mixed-Black women in the UK. Services monitor inequities through outcomes and experience data, yet evidence of racism often results in inaction, and existing explanations rely mainly on staff perspectives. We drew on Black mothers and community advocates accounts to explain what stops monitoring of racism from leading to action, and how they propose evidence of racism should be recorded so that it does. Methods: This co-produced qualitative study was underpinned by critical realism and Black feminist thought. Four focus groups were held in London from June to July 2026 with nine Black, African, Caribbean and mixed-Black mothers who used NHS maternity services and seven community advocates. Lived experience co-researchers co-led the study design, data collection and analysis. We used critical realist thematic analysis to propose mechanisms explaining participants accounts, each tested against rival explanations. Results: We propose three mechanisms: credibility discounting, evidence neutralisation and containment of change. Participants described Black womens accounts being discounted until someone else raised the same concern, consistent with testimonial injustice. Recorded evidence appeared to be neutralised through audit culture, as concerns were acknowledged or deflected without action. Change that would shift power or accountability appeared to be contained, consistent with institutional racism. Participants also described harm from staff who shared their racial identity, linked to internalised racism intersecting with language and migration, and to workplace cultures in which Black staff are also dismissed; we interpret this harm as a possible outcome of these mechanisms. Participants proposed that services account for their response to each concern, supported by community-generated evidence, independent observation, qualitative routes and ethnicity-disaggregated data. This would require protection for those who raise concerns and sustained funding and backing for action. Conclusions: Our findings suggest more evidence alone is unlikely to address racism in maternity services. An independently reviewed record of how services respond to each concern could show when they do not act. Change is more likely where services shift power and resources to community organisations working with Black families, while remaining accountable for acting on evidence of racism.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
medRxiv
Published
2026-11-15
DOI
https://doi.org/10.64898/2026.11.13.26368002
Primary Topic
Racial and Ethnic Identity Research
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

When will it ever be enough? Black mothers and community advocates perspectives on why evidence of racism in English maternity care does not lead to action: a co-produced focus group study

Phoebe Averill, Helen Ward, Sarindi Aryasinghe, Sabrina Das et al.
medRxiv
Racial and Ethnic Identity Research
preprint

When will it ever be enough? Black mothers and community advocates perspectives on why evidence of racism in English maternity care does not lead to action: a co-produced focus group study

Phoebe Averill, Helen Ward, Sarindi Aryasinghe, Sabrina Das, Phayza Fudlalla, Ruchi K. Wadhwa, Carole Waithe, Susan Ibuanokpe, Rhianna Newby-Mayers, Gabriella Sarpong
preprint en

Abstract

Background: Racism shapes the maternity care and outcomes of Black, African, Caribbean and mixed-Black women in the UK. Services monitor inequities through outcomes and experience data, yet evidence of racism often results in inaction, and existing explanations rely mainly on staff perspectives. We drew on Black mothers and community advocates accounts to explain what stops monitoring of racism from leading to action, and how they propose evidence of racism should be recorded so that it does. Methods: This co-produced qualitative study was underpinned by critical realism and Black feminist thought. Four focus groups were held in London from June to July 2026 with nine Black, African, Caribbean and mixed-Black mothers who used NHS maternity services and seven community advocates. Lived experience co-researchers co-led the study design, data collection and analysis. We used critical realist thematic analysis to propose mechanisms explaining participants accounts, each tested against rival explanations. Results: We propose three mechanisms: credibility discounting, evidence neutralisation and containment of change. Participants described Black womens accounts being discounted until someone else raised the same concern, consistent with testimonial injustice. Recorded evidence appeared to be neutralised through audit culture, as concerns were acknowledged or deflected without action. Change that would shift power or accountability appeared to be contained, consistent with institutional racism. Participants also described harm from staff who shared their racial identity, linked to internalised racism intersecting with language and migration, and to workplace cultures in which Black staff are also dismissed; we interpret this harm as a possible outcome of these mechanisms. Participants proposed that services account for their response to each concern, supported by community-generated evidence, independent observation, qualitative routes and ethnicity-disaggregated data. This would require protection for those who raise concerns and sustained funding and backing for action. Conclusions: Our findings suggest more evidence alone is unlikely to address racism in maternity services. An independently reviewed record of how services respond to each concern could show when they do not act. Change is more likely where services shift power and resources to community organisations working with Black families, while remaining accountable for acting on evidence of racism.

medRxiv
Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust (GB), King's College London (GB), Imperial College London (GB)
Racial and Ethnic Identity Research
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon