Legal Status and Political Legitimacy in Somali Permanent and Transitional Governance since Independence: Between Rule and Anarchy

The relationship between social legitimacy and legal power/authority in permanent and transitional governance is examined in this essay. In 1960, Somalia gained independence and became known as the Somali Democratic Republic. The dictatorial government of Siad Barre was a major factor in the Somali Democratic Republic's collapse after 31 years of independence and two more administrations. Bringing Somali ethnological clan groups together to rebuild the nation-state has been a major problem for the international community. Institutional fragility is a common feature of transitional societies, where political stability and public trust cannot be sustained by constitutional legitimacy alone. This study examines how formal state institutions—primarily the federal government, federal member states, traditional sectors, and international and national organisation or groups that are socially embedded actors—negotiate governance authority in contexts of political transition, post-conflict reconstruction, and institutional uncertainty using a qualitative normative approach. According to different perspectives, the introduction of openness, accountability, participation, rule of law, and societal legitimacy often diminishes illegitimate authority. However, a large number of participants agreed that the rule of law is crucial to any government and that violations of its principles can result in arbitrariness and defilements/violations of fundamental rights. However, despite not having a formal constitutional standing, informal governance systems may become more widely accepted in society even though they are not linked to social legitimacy. The paper presents the idea of "legitimacy-fluid governance," which describes the dynamic transfer of power between formal and informal institutions based on societal approval, public trust, and political performance. The study identified the role of the rule of law in guaranteeing good governance and how corruption and power abuse have gravely threatened it, which in turn has an impact on good governance. This study validates that the demise of subsequent governments, whether permanent or transitional, since independence on July 1st, 1960, to the present day, is fundamentally shaped by the dynamic interaction between legal authority and social legitimacy. In conclusion, as the Somali political system has undergone changes across the three stages of governance, the study addresses the proposed definition of legitimacy and the issue of political disorder within the Somali federal government, while also offering satisfactory solutions to the problems identified in the study. In addition, customs and clans have gained strong social recognition over the years, even though they lack formal constitutional standing and operate informally in conflict resolution at both local and federal levels, as clan conflicts transcend the clan-based federal states.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Journal of Political Science and International Relations
Published
2026-11-14
DOI
https://doi.org/10.11648/j.jpsir.20260904.15
Primary Topic
Peacebuilding and International Security
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Legal Status and Political Legitimacy in Somali Permanent and Transitional Governance since Independence: Between Rule and Anarchy

Abdiqani Ahmed Farah, Abdifatah Khalif
Journal of Political Science and International Relations
Peacebuilding and International Security
article

Legal Status and Political Legitimacy in Somali Permanent and Transitional Governance since Independence: Between Rule and Anarchy

Abdiqani Ahmed Farah, Abdifatah Khalif
article en

Abstract

The relationship between social legitimacy and legal power/authority in permanent and transitional governance is examined in this essay. In 1960, Somalia gained independence and became known as the Somali Democratic Republic. The dictatorial government of Siad Barre was a major factor in the Somali Democratic Republic's collapse after 31 years of independence and two more administrations. Bringing Somali ethnological clan groups together to rebuild the nation-state has been a major problem for the international community. Institutional fragility is a common feature of transitional societies, where political stability and public trust cannot be sustained by constitutional legitimacy alone. This study examines how formal state institutions—primarily the federal government, federal member states, traditional sectors, and international and national organisation or groups that are socially embedded actors—negotiate governance authority in contexts of political transition, post-conflict reconstruction, and institutional uncertainty using a qualitative normative approach. According to different perspectives, the introduction of openness, accountability, participation, rule of law, and societal legitimacy often diminishes illegitimate authority. However, a large number of participants agreed that the rule of law is crucial to any government and that violations of its principles can result in arbitrariness and defilements/violations of fundamental rights. However, despite not having a formal constitutional standing, informal governance systems may become more widely accepted in society even though they are not linked to social legitimacy. The paper presents the idea of "legitimacy-fluid governance," which describes the dynamic transfer of power between formal and informal institutions based on societal approval, public trust, and political performance. The study identified the role of the rule of law in guaranteeing good governance and how corruption and power abuse have gravely threatened it, which in turn has an impact on good governance. This study validates that the demise of subsequent governments, whether permanent or transitional, since independence on July 1st, 1960, to the present day, is fundamentally shaped by the dynamic interaction between legal authority and social legitimacy. In conclusion, as the Somali political system has undergone changes across the three stages of governance, the study addresses the proposed definition of legitimacy and the issue of political disorder within the Somali federal government, while also offering satisfactory solutions to the problems identified in the study. In addition, customs and clans have gained strong social recognition over the years, even though they lack formal constitutional standing and operate informally in conflict resolution at both local and federal levels, as clan conflicts transcend the clan-based federal states.

Journal of Political Science and International RelationsVol. 9(4)
East Africa University (SO)
Peacebuilding and International Security
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon