Resenha crítica da obra: “Defending the political constitution”
This critical review examines the work Defending the Political Constitution by Richard Bellamy, published in 2026 by Oxford University Press, in which the author argues for the centrality of democratic processes in the definition, protection, and realization of fundamental rights. Drawing a distinction between political constitutionalism and legal constitutionalism, Bellamy questions the legitimacy of delegating constitutional decisions to the courts, maintaining that parliamentary deliberation, political equality, and democratic accountability serve as essential mechanisms for limiting power. The book further explores challenges arising from the expansion of judicial review, the internationalization of human rights, the rise of populism, and the erosion of representative institutions. This critical analysis contrasts Bellamy’s arguments with the contributions of Ronald Dworkin and John Rawls, particularly regarding the protection of minorities against potential majoritarian abuses. Within the Brazilian context, the discussion addresses the increasingly prominent role of the Supreme Federal Court, weighing both the risks associated with the concentration of judicial power and its significance for the realization of fundamental rights. In this regard, the ruling in Direct Action of Unconstitutionality (ADI) No. 4,275 is highlighted as an example of judicial intervention aimed at protecting historically vulnerable groups. The review concludes that, while Bellamy’s proposal offers a significant contribution to contemporary constitutional theory, its application faces limitations in democracies characterized by structural inequalities and institutional fragility. Nevertheless, the work reaffirms the importance of political participation, the strengthening of representative institutions, and democratic legitimacy in building a constitutional order committed to the protection of rights.
Authors
- Tharyn Andressa Faustino Garrett
Publication Details
- Journal
- NeoKrísis - Revista de Teorias Políticas e Jurídicas
- Published
- 2026-11-15
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.48075/ah464264
- Primary Topic
- Comparative constitutional jurisprudence studies
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00