Attribution Without Verification: Operative Standards for Epistemic Responsibility Gaps. A Response to Veluwenkamp (2025)
The responsibility gap debate has produced four developed positions: responsibility injustice as an epistemic residue, an internalism on which gaps are inevitable and unproblematic, conceptual re-engineering into epistemic gaps and control misalignment, and redescription as responsibility for unintentional action. Each ultimately returns institutional attention to the attribution of responsibility in particular cases. This paper argues that on that shared target every remedy stops at the same place, because the internal states and counterfactual facts that finally settle desert cannot be verified by any third party, a premise the debate itself has established. A theorem is then stated in two directions of equal standing. HYC1: an institution facing a bounded deadline with no admissible abstention, about a state it cannot verify, will operate a standard mapping observable indicators and procedural facts to determinations. HYC2: where such verification is unavailable and a determination has nonetheless been issued, the deciding institution has operated such a standard. Attribution practice is such a standard, and it runs without an error signal, so a standard that mistracks responsibility is undetectable from inside the practice. Six design principles answer that feature, each by way of a further premise: publicity of indicators, recorded warrant, standing for the assessed, minority accommodation as calibration correction, institutional pluralism, and mandatory expiry. The framework is applied to a case of attribution in artificial intelligence research in which this paper is itself an instance, and the result answers the design instruction with which the founding paper of the debate closed.
Authors
- Kenji Yamada (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0006-0381-1185)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-15
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24254595
- Primary Topic
- Feminist Epistemology and Gender Studies
- Type
- preprint