Why Should Public Research Support Rely on Competition?
Public research funding aims to support scientific inquiry and the production of public knowledge. Scarcity requires allocation, but does not logically require competitive ranking; fair conduct within a competition cannot, by itself, justify the choice to allocate support competitively. This paper distinguishes public purposes, allocation mechanisms, and procedural safeguards, and examines five related questions: the justification of competition, changes to eligibility rules, the possible reproduction of evaluative standards through recurrent expert review, application burdens, and the potential displacement of public goals by administrative performance. Changes in US National Institutes of Health resubmission policy provide a bounded institutional illustration. Existing studies motivate, but do not establish, claims about innovation suppression, reviewer advantage, or social loss. The paper proposes testable mechanisms and differentiated evidentiary standards. Its central claim is that competitive allocation requires justification independent of its own procedural compliance and performance metrics.
Authors
- Han Wang
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-14
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24221305
- Primary Topic
- Research, Science, and Academia
- Type
- preprint