Situationships: A Modern Arena for Sexual Conflict in Human Mating (Conference Presentation)
Situationships are romantic relationships lacking clear direction or commitment. They remain underexplored in relationship science, despite their increasing prevalence. Evolutionary psychology provides a useful framework for investigating these contemporary relationship forms. Parental Investment Theory and Sexual Strategies Theory suggest that because women historically bore higher reproductive costs, selection has favored female-typical mating strategies for securing commitment and investment, whereas men’s lower obligatory investment has shaped adaptations to pursue low-cost sex and sexual variety. Sexual Conflict Theory suggests that one sex’s optimal strategy often imposes costs on the other. Situationships, by combining ongoing sexual access with minimal commitment obligations, are therefore hypothesized to align more closely with male-typical short-term mating strategies and to yield greater psychological costs for women. This overarching hypothesis was tested through a suite of directional predictions about motivations, experiences, and outcomes of situationships. A sample of 390 adults (68% women; MAge = 27.4) who had experienced at least one situationship completed an online survey assessing motives, relationship experiences, and a range of wellbeing outcomes. Findings largely supported theoretical expectations. Most reported sexual involvement (82.3%), yet only 9% of situationships transitioned into committed relationships. Men more often endorsed short-term motives and reported more benefits, including sexual freedom. Women more often endorsed long-term motives and reported higher levels of regret and negative wellbeing impact. Sociosexuality buffered women somewhat, higher partner mate value increased women’s commitment desire, and older women reported fewer negative effects; however, women’s sociosexuality levels were not especially high, suggesting that situationships pull in a different profile of women than those who usually participate in casual sexual relationships, which may help explain why most experienced significant costs. Findings suggest that situationships constitute a zone of sexual conflict that systematically advantage men while disproportionately undermining women’s wellbeing.
Authors
- M. Gräff
- Nicholas Alvaro Coles (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8583-5610)
- William Costello (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0346-6370)
- Saffron Marli Costello (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0004-0350-6194)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Open Science Framework
- Published
- 2026-11-15
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.17605/osf.io/6d9rx
- Primary Topic
- Evolutionary Psychology and Human Behavior
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00