Trust Beyond Words: Why Public Health Cannot Communicate Its Way Into Rebuilding Trust With the Public

Policy Points We challenge the assumption that communication failures are the central cause of declining trust. Amid a widely acknowledged crisis of trust in public health, we argue that an overemphasis on communication obscures deeper, upstream failures in the ability of public health to exercise authentic presence and accountability. Community listening and engagement should be a core metric of public health practice: Incentives for public health practice, such as program funding mechanisms, research funding, and leadership promotions, should expand or realign with a bias toward improving community engagement. Context The public health profession is experiencing a widely recognized crisis of trust among the communities it seeks to serve. Leading public health advocates have suggested that the roots of this crisis lie not in the inherent practices of public health, but rather in failures to communicate effectively with the public. Accordingly, they have proposed improved communication strategies as a primary response. Methods Drawing on philosophical literature and applied public health examples, we argue that efforts to restore trust between public health and communities must center on cultivating trustworthiness—an internal quality of public health professionals and institutions—rather than simply developing more effective strategies for eliciting trust through communication. Findings Trustworthiness is rarely established apart from concrete acts of patiently listening to and practically responding to the needs of communities. Without these practices of meaningful engagement, improvements in public health communication may simply reinforce a transmissive model of communication, one that seeks to cultivate public trust primarily to secure community adherence acceptance of public health priorities and interventions. This tendency toward transmissive communication is a subtle, yet pervasive feature of many contemporary proposals for addressing public health's crisis of trust. Conclusion Restoring public trust requires more than improving how public health communicates about its science and interventions. It requires cultivating the values, practices, and institutional arrangements that enable public health professionals and institutions to be meaningfully present in the communities they serve. Rather than prioritizing one‐way, transmissive unidirectional communication from at a distance, the profession must first develop the capacity to listen, respond, and demonstrate its trustworthiness through sustained engagement.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Milbank Quarterly
Published
2026-11-15
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1111/1468-0009.70138
Primary Topic
Public Health Policies and Education
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Trust Beyond Words: Why Public Health Cannot Communicate Its Way Into Rebuilding Trust With the Public

KARL JOHNSON, ZOEY KERNODLE
Milbank Quarterly
Public Health Policies and Education
article

Trust Beyond Words: Why Public Health Cannot Communicate Its Way Into Rebuilding Trust With the Public

KARL JOHNSON, ZOEY KERNODLE
article en

Abstract

Policy Points We challenge the assumption that communication failures are the central cause of declining trust. Amid a widely acknowledged crisis of trust in public health, we argue that an overemphasis on communication obscures deeper, upstream failures in the ability of public health to exercise authentic presence and accountability. Community listening and engagement should be a core metric of public health practice: Incentives for public health practice, such as program funding mechanisms, research funding, and leadership promotions, should expand or realign with a bias toward improving community engagement. Context The public health profession is experiencing a widely recognized crisis of trust among the communities it seeks to serve. Leading public health advocates have suggested that the roots of this crisis lie not in the inherent practices of public health, but rather in failures to communicate effectively with the public. Accordingly, they have proposed improved communication strategies as a primary response. Methods Drawing on philosophical literature and applied public health examples, we argue that efforts to restore trust between public health and communities must center on cultivating trustworthiness—an internal quality of public health professionals and institutions—rather than simply developing more effective strategies for eliciting trust through communication. Findings Trustworthiness is rarely established apart from concrete acts of patiently listening to and practically responding to the needs of communities. Without these practices of meaningful engagement, improvements in public health communication may simply reinforce a transmissive model of communication, one that seeks to cultivate public trust primarily to secure community adherence acceptance of public health priorities and interventions. This tendency toward transmissive communication is a subtle, yet pervasive feature of many contemporary proposals for addressing public health's crisis of trust. Conclusion Restoring public trust requires more than improving how public health communicates about its science and interventions. It requires cultivating the values, practices, and institutional arrangements that enable public health professionals and institutions to be meaningfully present in the communities they serve. Rather than prioritizing one‐way, transmissive unidirectional communication from at a distance, the profession must first develop the capacity to listen, respond, and demonstrate its trustworthiness through sustained engagement.

Milbank Quarterly
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill (US)
Public Health Policies and Education
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon