Who Decides, Who Answers? Democratic Accountability and the Institutional Life of Public Decisions
A public decision may be issued by one office while its decisive assumptions were established elsewhere. This division of labour is ordinary in administration, but it complicates who can explain a decision, who may challenge it and who has authority to amend it. This conceptual review develops a decision-pathway approach to democratic accountability by bringing scholarship on accountability relationships, institutional controls, participation and transparency into dialogue. It distinguishes four analytically useful moments: setting criteria, producing a case-specific judgement, giving reasons and enabling contestation, and revising decisions or rules. At each moment, responsibility is examined in terms of authority, evidence, audience and available remedy. The paper argues that administrative visibility and formal review mechanisms cannot, on their own, demonstrate whether the consequential choices in a decision pathway are open to meaningful challenge. It also identifies tensions between participation, consistency, privacy, timeliness and professional discretion. The proposed framework is an interpretive tool for comparing decision processes; it has not been empirically validated. The contribution is a set of questions for locating accountability gaps without assuming that every public body should use the same institutional design.
Authors
- Fatemeh Hajiali (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0005-8786-1069)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Figshare
- Published
- 2026-11-15
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.35013829
- Primary Topic
- Public Policy and Administration Research
- Type
- preprint