Abiogenesis: A Critical Survey of All Proposals and the Case for Closure-First Life — Introduction to a Series of New Proposals

This is a synthesis and hypothesis paper, not an experimental result. Autocatalytic sets are due to Kauffman (1971), wet-dry cycling to Deamer and others, vent chemistry to Russell / Wachtershauser, RNA World to Gilbert / Sutherland / Szostak, and metabolism-first ideas to Wachtershauser / Russell. None of those ideas are claimed as original here. The contribution of this paper is: 1. A systematic comparison of nine major abiogenesis proposals against the same five requirements: Feedstock, Energy, Heredity, Metabolism, Compartment.2. A formalization called Closure-First: life begins when a chemical network becomes causally closed — defined as catalytic closure + temporal closure + compartmental closure, expressed as P(S_{t+1} | S_t, E_t) > P(S_{t+1} | E_t).3. Five falsifiable predictions and a series roadmap (Papers II-VI) to test them. No claim in this paper is presented as experimentally proved. The falsifiers in Section 6 define what would kill the theory. This is Paper I — Introduction. Papers II-VI in the series will test one prediction each: the cycling threshold, hysteresis / memory, minimal closure size, RNA downstream, and geochemical signature. Abstract:Abiogenesis has no shortage of proposals. It has a shortage of a criterion for choosing between them. We survey nine major proposals: Primordial Soup, Hydrothermal Vent, RNA World, Metabolism-First, Lipid World, Clay World, Panspermia, Deep Hot Biosphere, and Thermodynamic proposals. We show each explains one necessary condition for life — feedstock, energy, heredity, metabolism, compartment — and fails to explain the others. We propose a unifying criterion: Causal Closure. Life begins when a chemical network becomes causally closed: its present increases the probability of its own past. RNA, proteins, lipids, and membranes are not origins. They are co-options of a network that already had closure. Key words: abiogenesisorigin of lifeautocatalytic setsRNA worldhydrothermal ventsprebiotic chemistrycausal closurehypothesis

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-15
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24236819
Primary Topic
Origins and Evolution of Life
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Abiogenesis: A Critical Survey of All Proposals and the Case for Closure-First Life — Introduction to a Series of New Proposals

Robert Aaron Tseglin
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Origins and Evolution of Life
article

Abiogenesis: A Critical Survey of All Proposals and the Case for Closure-First Life — Introduction to a Series of New Proposals

Robert Aaron Tseglin
article en

Abstract

This is a synthesis and hypothesis paper, not an experimental result. Autocatalytic sets are due to Kauffman (1971), wet-dry cycling to Deamer and others, vent chemistry to Russell / Wachtershauser, RNA World to Gilbert / Sutherland / Szostak, and metabolism-first ideas to Wachtershauser / Russell. None of those ideas are claimed as original here. The contribution of this paper is: 1. A systematic comparison of nine major abiogenesis proposals against the same five requirements: Feedstock, Energy, Heredity, Metabolism, Compartment.2. A formalization called Closure-First: life begins when a chemical network becomes causally closed — defined as catalytic closure + temporal closure + compartmental closure, expressed as P(S_{t+1} | S_t, E_t) > P(S_{t+1} | E_t).3. Five falsifiable predictions and a series roadmap (Papers II-VI) to test them. No claim in this paper is presented as experimentally proved. The falsifiers in Section 6 define what would kill the theory. This is Paper I — Introduction. Papers II-VI in the series will test one prediction each: the cycling threshold, hysteresis / memory, minimal closure size, RNA downstream, and geochemical signature. Abstract:Abiogenesis has no shortage of proposals. It has a shortage of a criterion for choosing between them. We survey nine major proposals: Primordial Soup, Hydrothermal Vent, RNA World, Metabolism-First, Lipid World, Clay World, Panspermia, Deep Hot Biosphere, and Thermodynamic proposals. We show each explains one necessary condition for life — feedstock, energy, heredity, metabolism, compartment — and fails to explain the others. We propose a unifying criterion: Causal Closure. Life begins when a chemical network becomes causally closed: its present increases the probability of its own past. RNA, proteins, lipids, and membranes are not origins. They are co-options of a network that already had closure. Key words: abiogenesisorigin of lifeautocatalytic setsRNA worldhydrothermal ventsprebiotic chemistrycausal closurehypothesis

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Origins and Evolution of Life
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon