Beyond SWOT; Critiquing Managerial Approaches in Public Asset Governance Research. A Review of Al Farisi, et al. (2024)
This paper examines the managerial tendency in public asset management research, particularly in the study of official government vehicles. Using Al Farisi et al. (2024) on fixed asset management strategies for official vehicles in the Riau Islands Provincial Government as the main object of analysis, this paper questions whether SWOT, IFE, EFE, and QSPM are sufficient to explain the complexity of public asset governance. This study applies a conceptual-critical review approach through three stages of analysis: descriptive reading, critical reading, and reconstructive reading. The analysis is informed by public governance, managerialism/New Public Management, institutional theory, and principal-agent theory. The review shows that Al Farisi et al. provide useful practical recommendations, including vehicle logos, GPS installation, technical regulations, improved asset management performance, functional positions, and sanctions. However, the article does not fully explain deeper issues such as weak compliance, poor monitoring, moral hazard, internal bureaucratic bias, and fragile accountability. Therefore, the problem of official vehicles is better understood as a form of governance failure, rather than merely a technical weakness in asset management. This paper argues that SWOT and similar managerial tools are useful for mapping strategies, but insufficient for explaining the broader governance complexity of public asset management. A governance-centered approach is therefore needed, one that emphasizes public accountability, institutional capacity, compliance culture, bureaucratic behavior, and oversight mechanisms.
Authors
- A. Faroby Falatehan (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-5392-5213)
- Dwi Rachmina (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1632-0178)
- Salman Al Farisi
- Zikrianul Fitrah
Publication Details
- Journal
- Journal Governance Bureaucratic Review
- Published
- 2026-11-16
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.31629/jgbr.v3i3.8473
- Primary Topic
- Public Policy and Administration Research
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00