The lensing offset of the Bullet Cluster (1E 0657-56) A sensitivity calculation in the Zg = G/c theory
theory The Bullet Cluster is often cited as direct proof of dark matter, because the gravitational lensing mass peak is about 200 kpc away from the X-ray gas peak, at the galaxies. This paper does not claim that there is no dark matter. It shows, with an exact calculation, that the position of the lensing peak is sensitive to the gas mass and to the size of the galaxy halo. In lensing models galaxies are modeled individually with a PIEMD profile, with r_core = 0.15 kpc and r_cut = 30-60 kpc. The 245 kpc is not the halo size, but the scale of the distribution of galaxy positions. The halo itself, which lenses, is only 30-50 kpc, effective Gaussian width about 40 kpc. The gas is wide, 150-628 kpc, from a beta-model with rc = 142 arcsec = 628 kpc, which its authors themselves call inadequate for a complex merging system. With the correct sizes, the critical gas fraction where the lensing peak flips from the gas to the galaxies is 75.0% for realistic smoothing sigma_s = 100 kpc. If the gas mass is corrected for clumping, non-thermal pressure, projection and the Zg Bg and dm/dt term, and the galaxy M/L is corrected, the true gas fraction goes from the measured 89% to 73.4%, which is 1.6 percentage points below the critical value. Then the lensing peak is at the galaxies, without dark matter, with gravitational impedance Zg = G/c. This is a sensitivity calculation, not a full lensing reconstruction. It shows that the Bullet does not exclude the Zg = G/c theory, because the error is larger than the difference. The 8 sigma quoted in the literature refers only to statistical noise, not to model sensitivity.
Authors
- József Kerényi (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0007-4154-9197)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Figshare
- Published
- 2026-11-15
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.35014156
- Primary Topic
- Galaxies: Formation, Evolution, Phenomena
- Type
- preprint