A Forensic Re-examination of Natalie Schilling's Linguistic Analysis of Audio Recordings from the September 11 Attacks
Abstract Linguist Natalie Schilling, commissioned by the International Center for 9/11 Justice, has concluded that the radio transmissions from American Airlines Flight 11, attributed to terrorist Mohamed Atta, have a relatively wide pitch range and contain r-dropping or r-weakening in the word “airport,” features she considers inconsistent with Arabic English. This investigation critically re-examines both claims. The wide pitch range she reports is shown to be an artifact of an algorithm unsuitable for aircraft transmissions. Careful analysis with the appropriate methodology reveals a pitch range narrower than that reported for both native British and Jordanian speakers of English. As for r-dropping, Schilling’s criterion—a steady third formant—is demonstrated to be flawed and prone to false positives in distorted and studio recordings. At present, distortion and filtering in the radio transmissions do not allow for a determination of whether the /r/ in “airport” was pronounced. The investigation also examines Schilling’s analyses of radio transmissions from United Airlines Flight 93 and a voicemail left by flight attendant CeeCee Lyles. Schilling suggested that the pilots’ second mayday call is contextually questionable and concluded that a noise in the voicemail is most likely a whispered “It’s a frame.” These claims are shown to be unsupported by evidence and based on questionable interpretations of audio that, by Schilling’s own admission, is too degraded for a definitive determination.
Authors
- Søren Roest Korsgaard (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0008-1550-1787)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-15
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24235673
- Primary Topic
- Phonetics and Phonology Research
- Type
- preprint