Making Climate Change Adaptation Governable: Comparing State‐Level Adaptation Policy Architectures in Germany and Australia

ABSTRACT In federated systems of government, state governments have become pivotal in steering climate change adaptation through a range of instruments. This includes legislation, regulation, policies, strategies, guidelines, and sector plans that structure responsibilities and resource distribution, and provide direction within sub‐national systems. Yet, compared to research on national and local levels, state‐level adaptation governance remains under‐examined. Addressing this gap, we analyse adaptation policy architectures of Baden‐Württemberg (Germany) and Victoria (Australia) to examine how these architectures authorise, structure, and direct climate change adaptation across the wider sub‐national system. Using qualitative document analysis of key state‐level laws, strategies, and sector plans, contextualised by expert interviews, we undertake a frames analysis, using climate change adaptation policy frames of hazards, climate impacts, risk management, vulnerability, and resilience, to illustrate how climate change is problematised and how responsibilities and instrument mixes are assembled across both cases. By employing analytical frames, we find that middle‐tier policy architectures actively constitute sub‐national adaptation governance in three ways: they construct the scales at which adaptation becomes actionable; encode distinct coordination logics; and institutionalise adaptation through different combinations of rules, resources, and routines. Baden‐Württemberg primarily does this through territorially and vertically organised statutory planning, whereas Victoria predominantly relies on the horizontal orchestration of heterogeneous system (or sector‐based) adaptation plans. The comparison identifies the State middle tier as an important site of adaptation system design, where policy arrangements distribute the burdens of translation, capacity, and accountability across jurisdictions and sectors in context‐specific ways. These findings call for greater attention to the design of state‐level policy instruments when examining how adaptation becomes governable and actionable across sub‐national systems. For, rather than only “enabling” local action, state‐level adaptation efforts configure what becomes legible, governable and actionable in the first place.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Environmental Policy and Governance
Published
2026-11-15
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1002/eet.70165
Primary Topic
Sustainability and Climate Change Governance
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Making Climate Change Adaptation Governable: Comparing State‐Level Adaptation Policy Architectures in Germany and Australia

Hartmut Fünfgeld, Lisa de Kleyn, Dennis Fila, LAUREN A. RICKARDS et al.
Environmental Policy and Governance
Sustainability and Climate Change Governance
article

Making Climate Change Adaptation Governable: Comparing State‐Level Adaptation Policy Architectures in Germany and Australia

Hartmut Fünfgeld, Lisa de Kleyn, Dennis Fila, LAUREN A. RICKARDS, Todd Denham, Alexandra Speidel, Sophie Schmidt
article en

Abstract

ABSTRACT In federated systems of government, state governments have become pivotal in steering climate change adaptation through a range of instruments. This includes legislation, regulation, policies, strategies, guidelines, and sector plans that structure responsibilities and resource distribution, and provide direction within sub‐national systems. Yet, compared to research on national and local levels, state‐level adaptation governance remains under‐examined. Addressing this gap, we analyse adaptation policy architectures of Baden‐Württemberg (Germany) and Victoria (Australia) to examine how these architectures authorise, structure, and direct climate change adaptation across the wider sub‐national system. Using qualitative document analysis of key state‐level laws, strategies, and sector plans, contextualised by expert interviews, we undertake a frames analysis, using climate change adaptation policy frames of hazards, climate impacts, risk management, vulnerability, and resilience, to illustrate how climate change is problematised and how responsibilities and instrument mixes are assembled across both cases. By employing analytical frames, we find that middle‐tier policy architectures actively constitute sub‐national adaptation governance in three ways: they construct the scales at which adaptation becomes actionable; encode distinct coordination logics; and institutionalise adaptation through different combinations of rules, resources, and routines. Baden‐Württemberg primarily does this through territorially and vertically organised statutory planning, whereas Victoria predominantly relies on the horizontal orchestration of heterogeneous system (or sector‐based) adaptation plans. The comparison identifies the State middle tier as an important site of adaptation system design, where policy arrangements distribute the burdens of translation, capacity, and accountability across jurisdictions and sectors in context‐specific ways. These findings call for greater attention to the design of state‐level policy instruments when examining how adaptation becomes governable and actionable across sub‐national systems. For, rather than only “enabling” local action, state‐level adaptation efforts configure what becomes legible, governable and actionable in the first place.

Environmental Policy and Governance
University of Freiburg (DE), La Trobe University (AU), Melbourne Institute of Technology (AU), Monash University (AU), Martin Luther University Halle-Wittenberg (DE), RMIT University (AU)
Sustainability and Climate Change Governance
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon