Legal Certainty in Share Acquisition Agreements: An Examination of Divergent Judicial Reasoning
Share acquisition transactions may give rise to disputes when the underlying agreement fails to satisfy the legal requirements for a valid contract but is nevertheless invoked as the basis for claiming the performance of contractual obligations. This study examines the validity of a Letter of Agreement to Sell (Surat Kesepakatan Menjual) under Article 1320 of the Indonesian Civil Code and the consistency of the ratio decidendi in judicial decisions concerning the case of PT Pepper Tree Investama v. Junaedy Tanujaya et al. The study employs a normative legal research methodology, incorporating statutory, case, and conceptual approaches, to qualitatively analyze primary and secondary legal sources. The findings reveal divergent judicial assessments by the District Court and the High Court regarding the fulfillment of the essential elements of a valid agreement, particularly mutual consent, the legal authority of the parties, and the certainty of the subject matter of the transaction. The Supreme Court upheld the High Court’s decision at both the cassation and judicial review stages. This study concludes that a breach-of-contract (wanprestasi) claim requires prior proof of the existence of a valid and legally binding agreement. Establishing such an agreement is essential to ensuring legal certainty in business transactions.
Authors
- Franziska Martha Ratu Runturambi
- Hidayah Nurhandini
Institutions
- Pancasila University (ID)
Publication Details
- Journal
- JIHK
- Published
- 2026-11-15
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.46924/jihk.v8i2.557
- Primary Topic
- Indonesian Legal and Regulatory Studies
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00