Literary voice, cultural meaning, and human revision in large language model translation from 2022 to 2026
Large Language Models (LLMs) produce literary translations that read fluently, yet fluency reveals little about whether a narrator's voice, a poem's indeterminacy, or a culturally loaded reference survives. This systematic review examined how literary quality has been defined and measured in empirical studies of LLM literary translation, how far different kinds of evidence converge, and under which conditions prompting and human revision alter the preservation of literary features in translated texts. Semantic Scholar and Crossref searches, journal-targeted queries, and citation chasing covered January 2022 to September 5, 2026, and eligibility was restricted to journal articles from Scopus-listed sources. Forty-one studies were included, 28 extracted from full texts and 13 from abstracts, and each was appraised on nine validity domains without a summed score. The evidence is concentrated on Chinese and Arabic source texts, English targets (28 studies), and GPT models (37 studies), and 28 studies relied on a single evaluation method. Accuracy and fluency often matched or exceeded published human translations, whereas narrator differentiation, culturally framed stances, symbolic references, and taboo forces were compressed or neutralized in better-controlled designs. Overlap metrics broadly agreed with expert or reader judgments in only one of the seven studies reporting both, and reader backgrounds changed rankings. Prompt effects were model-specific and sometimes traded stylistic gains for unsupported additions, while human revision appeared only in case- and practice-based designs. A five-layer evaluation framework is proposed in which claims about voice and culture require evidence at the layers they invoke, together with research priorities for Indonesian and other underrepresented literature.
Authors
- Devina Antania Putri Maharianto
Publication Details
- Journal
- Journal of Language and Literature Inquiry
- Published
- 2026-11-15
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.55942/jlli.v1i2.2364
- Primary Topic
- Translation Studies and Practices
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00