From expectations to performance: a mixed-method approach evaluating newly-introduced cattle breeds in Himba pastoral systems

Abstract In Namibia, livestock improvement programmes promoted genetic “upgrading” in communal areas through breeding-bull distribution to improve productivity and carcass quality, reflecting perceptions that indigenous Nguni cattle’s small body size and low growth rate, generate lower returns when sold. Himba pastoralists have also independently introduced new cattle breeds and crosses, expecting higher milk and meat production. However, whether these productive advantages translate into better reproductive and economic performance under highly-variable pastoral conditions remains poorly understood. Data were collected using mixed-methods. In 44 semi-structured interviews, three group discussions, and extended participatory observation, Himba pastoralists' motivations and expectations for keeping introduced breeds and maintaining breed diversity were examined. We compared age at first calving (AFC), inter-calving interval (ICI), factors affecting reproduction, and sale prices among indigenous, acquired, and crossbred cattle based on 27 progeny-history interviews covering 125 cows and longitudinal cattle-sale records from 36 herds in three study locations in Kunene North. Pastoralists valued acquired and crossbred cattle for their higher milk-production potential, meat yield, and social status, whereas Nguni cattle were valued for reproductive performance, maintaining good body condition during dry-season and demanding less labour. Nguni cows had a mean AFC of 43.7 months, similar to crossbreds (43.7 months) but earlier than acquired breeds (52.9 months). Their mean ICI was also shorter (15.0 months) than acquired (18.6 months) and crossbred (18.4 months). While droughts mainly affected Nguni reproduction, acquired and crossbred cattle could not fully meet their higher nutritional requirements during regular dry-seasons, partly because they were kept for their milk-production potential. Breed group was not significantly associated with sale price after accounting for age–sex class, season, and sale-location (p = 0.465). These findings show that higher production potential alone does not determine cattle performance in pastoral systems. Under dry, highly-variable conditions, features enabling use of scarce, dispersed forage resources, and maintaining reproductive performance become important. Livestock improvement strategies should recognize pastoralists’ detailed knowledge of breeds’ performance under environmental and husbandry conditions of their production systems, to reduce failure risk in interventions aimed at enhancing milk and meat output.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Research Square
Published
2026-11-14
DOI
https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-11483504/v1
Primary Topic
Livestock Farming and Management
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

From expectations to performance: a mixed-method approach evaluating newly-introduced cattle breeds in Himba pastoral systems

Lilli Scheiterle, Brigitte Kaufmann, Kateuru Tjiuana, Wilhelmina Kakwali Lyuuvika Nuule
Research Square
Livestock Farming and Management
preprint

From expectations to performance: a mixed-method approach evaluating newly-introduced cattle breeds in Himba pastoral systems

Lilli Scheiterle, Brigitte Kaufmann, Kateuru Tjiuana, Wilhelmina Kakwali Lyuuvika Nuule
preprint en

Abstract

Abstract In Namibia, livestock improvement programmes promoted genetic “upgrading” in communal areas through breeding-bull distribution to improve productivity and carcass quality, reflecting perceptions that indigenous Nguni cattle’s small body size and low growth rate, generate lower returns when sold. Himba pastoralists have also independently introduced new cattle breeds and crosses, expecting higher milk and meat production. However, whether these productive advantages translate into better reproductive and economic performance under highly-variable pastoral conditions remains poorly understood. Data were collected using mixed-methods. In 44 semi-structured interviews, three group discussions, and extended participatory observation, Himba pastoralists' motivations and expectations for keeping introduced breeds and maintaining breed diversity were examined. We compared age at first calving (AFC), inter-calving interval (ICI), factors affecting reproduction, and sale prices among indigenous, acquired, and crossbred cattle based on 27 progeny-history interviews covering 125 cows and longitudinal cattle-sale records from 36 herds in three study locations in Kunene North. Pastoralists valued acquired and crossbred cattle for their higher milk-production potential, meat yield, and social status, whereas Nguni cattle were valued for reproductive performance, maintaining good body condition during dry-season and demanding less labour. Nguni cows had a mean AFC of 43.7 months, similar to crossbreds (43.7 months) but earlier than acquired breeds (52.9 months). Their mean ICI was also shorter (15.0 months) than acquired (18.6 months) and crossbred (18.4 months). While droughts mainly affected Nguni reproduction, acquired and crossbred cattle could not fully meet their higher nutritional requirements during regular dry-seasons, partly because they were kept for their milk-production potential. Breed group was not significantly associated with sale price after accounting for age–sex class, season, and sale-location (p = 0.465). These findings show that higher production potential alone does not determine cattle performance in pastoral systems. Under dry, highly-variable conditions, features enabling use of scarce, dispersed forage resources, and maintaining reproductive performance become important. Livestock improvement strategies should recognize pastoralists’ detailed knowledge of breeds’ performance under environmental and husbandry conditions of their production systems, to reduce failure risk in interventions aimed at enhancing milk and meat output.

Research Square
Namibia University of Science and Technology (NA), Deutsches Institut für Tropische und Subtropische Landwirtschaft (DE)
Livestock Farming and Management
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon