Cumulative Environmental Harm and Individual Criminal Responsibility: Scientific Causation, Forensic Attribution, and the Limits of International Criminal Law

The prosecution of serious environmental harm under international criminal law confronts a structural evidentiary problem: ecological destruction frequently results from cumulative, geographically distributed, and temporally extended activities involving multiple actors, while criminal responsibility must be established in relation to identifiable natural persons and legally defined offenses. Environmental degradation may be scientifically demonstrable without necessarily establishing the criminal conduct, mental element, causal relationship, jurisdictional conditions, or individual mode of liability required by the Rome Statute. This article examines the relationship between cumulative environmental harm and individual criminal responsibility through an interdisciplinary framework combining international criminal law, environmental forensic science, criminology, behavioral psychology, and forensic anthropology. It distinguishes environmental damage as a physical phenomenon, environmental damage as evidence relevant to an existing international crime, and ecocide as a proposed autonomous international offense. Particular attention is given to Article 8(2)(b)(iv) of the Rome Statute, the International Criminal Court Office of the Prosecutor's 2025 Policy on Addressing Environmental Damage Through the Rome Statute, and the limitations of attributing complex ecological outcomes to individual perpetrators. The article argues that environmental forensic evidence should be organized around four distinct questions: the identification and measurement of ecological damage; the reconstruction of its causal pathways; the identification of the accused person's contribution to the relevant conduct; and the demonstration of the applicable mental and jurisdictional elements. It proposes a structured evidentiary model that distinguishes scientific attribution from legal attribution, avoids the automatic conversion of environmental harm into proof of criminal intent, and accounts for uncertainty, cumulative causation, organizational conduct, and differential impacts on affected communities. The principal conclusion is that the effective prosecution of environmental dimensions of international crimes requires neither an expansion of existing offenses by interpretive shortcut nor an indiscriminate reliance on ecological indicators. It requires scientifically defensible evidence connected to the precise legal elements of an existing crime, while recognizing that the future criminalization of ecocide remains a separate legislative question.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Figshare
Published
2026-11-14
DOI
https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.35011471
Primary Topic
International Law and Human Rights
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

Cumulative Environmental Harm and Individual Criminal Responsibility: Scientific Causation, Forensic Attribution, and the Limits of International Criminal Law

Pommier Gallo, PhD., Sergio
Figshare
International Law and Human Rights
preprint

Cumulative Environmental Harm and Individual Criminal Responsibility: Scientific Causation, Forensic Attribution, and the Limits of International Criminal Law

Pommier Gallo, PhD., Sergio
preprint en

Abstract

The prosecution of serious environmental harm under international criminal law confronts a structural evidentiary problem: ecological destruction frequently results from cumulative, geographically distributed, and temporally extended activities involving multiple actors, while criminal responsibility must be established in relation to identifiable natural persons and legally defined offenses. Environmental degradation may be scientifically demonstrable without necessarily establishing the criminal conduct, mental element, causal relationship, jurisdictional conditions, or individual mode of liability required by the Rome Statute. This article examines the relationship between cumulative environmental harm and individual criminal responsibility through an interdisciplinary framework combining international criminal law, environmental forensic science, criminology, behavioral psychology, and forensic anthropology. It distinguishes environmental damage as a physical phenomenon, environmental damage as evidence relevant to an existing international crime, and ecocide as a proposed autonomous international offense. Particular attention is given to Article 8(2)(b)(iv) of the Rome Statute, the International Criminal Court Office of the Prosecutor's 2025 Policy on Addressing Environmental Damage Through the Rome Statute, and the limitations of attributing complex ecological outcomes to individual perpetrators. The article argues that environmental forensic evidence should be organized around four distinct questions: the identification and measurement of ecological damage; the reconstruction of its causal pathways; the identification of the accused person's contribution to the relevant conduct; and the demonstration of the applicable mental and jurisdictional elements. It proposes a structured evidentiary model that distinguishes scientific attribution from legal attribution, avoids the automatic conversion of environmental harm into proof of criminal intent, and accounts for uncertainty, cumulative causation, organizational conduct, and differential impacts on affected communities. The principal conclusion is that the effective prosecution of environmental dimensions of international crimes requires neither an expansion of existing offenses by interpretive shortcut nor an indiscriminate reliance on ecological indicators. It requires scientifically defensible evidence connected to the precise legal elements of an existing crime, while recognizing that the future criminalization of ecocide remains a separate legislative question.

Figshare
International Law and Human Rights
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon