The Shape of Logic: What Arithmetic Leaves of a Comparison with No First Side
We ask what the laws of identity require when the comparison of two quantities p and q is valued by a number. For a value they are three: only sameness has the value of sameness; the ratio x = p/q and its reverse 1/x have one value (no first side); the values of two comparisons fix those of their composites xy and x/y. (1) The two values of ordinary logic break the third law. (2) All three hold exactly when the value forgets which side came first and nothing else; they fix no form. For a value with no first side, computed from x by the four operations and not constant: (3) it gives x + 1/x back by them exactly when it is x + 1/x up to a change of scale t ↦ (αt + β)/(γt + δ), a classical step; asked of all complex ratios, the three laws themselves leave a(x + 1/x) + b; (4) the main result: the total, or the product, of its two composite values is computed from the two values by the same operations, by a rule not given in advance, exactly when it is xn + x−n up to a change of scale. (5) For n = 1 the chosen settings sameness at zero, no ceiling and unit 1/2 give (p − q)2/(2pq); on another scale the same value is the relative gap ((p − q)/(p + q))2. (6) For differences and angles the same theorems hold, with t2 and cos θ for x + 1/x. Premises, argued and not proved: these are the laws of identity; a value and the way back from it are computed by arithmetic on the quantities themselves; quantities are compared by their ratio.
Authors
- Jonathan Washburn (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0001-8868-7497)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-14
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24221196
- Primary Topic
- Advanced Algebra and Logic
- Type
- preprint