The “Clear or Unclear?” Test: Clarifying the Meaning of Criminal Law Measures (Maatregel) in Indonesia’s System of Criminal Sanctions
Ideally, the distinction between punishments and measures (maatregelen) in a dual-track system should reflect the grounds for imposing each sanction and the criteria governing its severity. In Indonesian criminal law, however, statutory labels do not consistently clarify why rights are restricted or how the duration of those restrictions is determined. This study develops criteria for distinguishing punishments from measures and examines their classification under the National Criminal Code and selected sectoral legislation. It uses qualitative doctrinal research, applying textual and systematic interpretation and the Seven-P Test to legislation, judicial decisions, and scholarship. The findings classify community service and supervision as punishments because their imposition and severity follow sentencing criteria. Drug rehabilitation is therapeutic when tailored to clinical needs, while environmental remediation is restorative when calibrated to the harm requiring repair. Chemical castration displays strong punitive features, whereas electronic monitoring serves a preventive supervisory function. Neither can be conclusively classified under the provisions examined because the criteria for determining duration remain unclear. These findings support codifying general criteria for measures, particularly the grounds for imposition, the calibration of restrictions, and the conditions for their review.
Authors
- Rendy Airlangga
- Adinda Ayani
Publication Details
- Journal
- Jurisprudensi Jurnal Ilmu Syariah Perundang-undangan Ekonomi Islam
- Published
- 2026-11-15
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.32505/jurisprudensi.v18i3.16286
- Primary Topic
- Criminal Law and Policy
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00